CHAPTER I - Energy Audit Overview
Welcome to a new way of learning science. In this course you will be asked to work as a member of a student team conducting an energy audit of your high school. You will take scientific measurements, question school staff, and obtain various kinds of information related to how your school uses energy. As you finish each investigation, you will write a scientific report with graphs and recommendations and present it to school officials. Your team's recommendations will cost the school little or no money and, if acted upon, will likely save at least 10 percent of last year's energy bill. These savings can continue this year and in the years to come. Is this a lot of money? In this study you will find out. Dollars saved may be available for such things as computers, athletic events, school dances, or for other school needs. As important, energy savings help the earth by reducing resource use and environmental pollution.
You will find that your school uses lots of energy, and that energy costs both money and the environment! Dollars are leaking out of your school every day, and it is up to you to find out the location and size of the leaks. In this workbook you are asked to find information. So, who has this information or where can you find it? It is up to you to find the right people and get the information you need; much like detectives investigating a crime scene. As in any investigation, you will collect a lot of information, develop a list of suspects, organize your information, and present your findings along with recommendations. Let's look at an example of school energy use. At Roosevelt High School in Portland Oregon, the electricity, fuel oil, and natural gas bills for the 1993 school year came to $109,943. Of that, $73,199 was for electricity; $23,177 for #5 fuel oil; and $13,567 for natural gas. The electricity bill for November of 1992, just one month, was $6,544. What was the electricity used for? You probably will think of lights. But, what other parts of your school use electricity? Where are other energy forms used in your school? Often about 10% of the energy cost of your high school can easily be saved. Can you or your team meet or beat this goal?
| The problem of identifying and capturing energy savings is very real. Tools you will use to answer these questions touch on many occupations. The energy manager is interested in tracking energy use in buildings, understanding opportunities for saving energy, and implementing those that are cost effective. The building operator increasingly needs to know how to maintain equipment, help occupants adopt energy saving strategies, and be able to suggest ways to save. Consultants, designers, and engineers need to be able to identify, analyze, and recommend energy saving strategies. |
A crime investigation is usually initiated with the discovery of a loss or injury. But how do you know that an "energy crime" has been committed and energy is being wasted. One tool is energy accounting. This is tracking your energy bills
Tracking expenditures helps prioritize where you should look first for savings, it enables you to measure whether steps you implement make a difference, and it permits you to spot unexpected anomalies that can lead to significant savings. In this workbook our focus will be expanded to include some other services such as water and garbage. Savings are often available by reducing water use and solid waste generated by your school.
The second major tool you will use is the audit. This involves going through your building to identify what is present. Where is energy being used, what type of energy, and how much is being used? How much solid waste is being collected from your school? Where is it generated and what are its characteristics? You then compare what you have with the cost and savings possible with other options to recommend specific actions.
In this project you will need to:
(1) collect data through both accounting and an audit of your school,
(2) analyze the data from the audit and tracking of existing usage (this will include graphing, correcting for climate and building usage, and calculating the economic cost-benefit of different alternatives),
(3) make recommendations based on your findings,
(4) write a report of your findings,
(5) present your findings to school officials and, lastly,
(6) evaluate what recommendations are adopted and how much energy and money is saved.
| In addition to saving money, reductions in energy use has significant benefits for the environment. Energy use is damaging our environment. What can we do? Surprisingly, some of the solutions are quite simple. We can improve efficiency to get the same benefit while using less energy. For example, worldwide sales of compact fluorescent lights increased 23 percent last year to 134 million bulbs. Substituting these bulbs for standard, incandescent lights will save up to 6,000 average megawatts of electricity each year (mega means million so megawatts means million watts). That is a savings equivalent to the annual energy output of ten large coal-fired power plants or about seven average nuclear plants. That's good news for the environment but also good news for consumers. A compact fluorescent used three hours daily will eventually save $35 even after taking into account the interest that could be earned by putting the additional money used to purchase the compact fluorescent light into a savings account. |
Energy Basics
Efficiency:
Laws of thermodynamics apply to both living (for example, you and me) and non-living (for example, your car or refrigerator) energy consumers. The concept of efficiency refers to the percentage of energy that can be transferred from one step to the next. The Second Law of Thermodynamics guarantees that you will lose in a transfer; but you can choose the transfer that is the most "efficient", the one that lets you use more of your energy.O
nly 16% of all commercially produced energy flowing through the US economy performs useful work. This means that 84% of all commercial energy used in the United States is wasted. About 41% of this energy is wasted automatically because of the Second Law of Thermodynamics. That leaves 43% of the commercial energy used in the United States that is unnecessarily wasted. An important point here is that efficiencies vary. A car that gets 40 miles per gallon of gas is more efficient than a car that gets 20 miles per gallon of gas. To go a given distance in the less efficient car you will burn twice as much gas as in a car that is twice as efficient. Since gasoline (energy) costs money, you will also spend twice as much money.Energy Conversion Efficiency
|
Energy Conversion Device |
Efficiency (% energy transferred) |
|
Incandescent light bulb |
5% |
|
Internal combustion engine (gasoline) |
10% |
|
Human body |
20-25% |
|
Fluorescent light |
45% |
|
Fuel cell |
60% |
Fuel Cost:
In addition to efficiency, often there are different types of fuels that can be used for the same task. For example, you could heat your house by burning $1 bills, $10 bills, or $100 bills in a woodstove. All would provide the same amount of heat, but use of $100 bills would cost 100 times the cost of using $1 bills. Using US paper currency, what would be the most cost efficient fuel to use?_____ $ 1 bills
_____ $ 10 bills
_____ $100 bills
1990 US Cost ($) of 250,000 kilocalories for heating space or water
|
Energy Source |
1990 US Cost (Dollars/250,000 kilocalories |
|
Electricity |
23.00 |
|
Propane |
8.00 |
|
Fuel Oil |
6.00 |
|
Kerosene |
5.55 |
|
Natural Gas |
5.50 |

In 1990, the average price of obtaining 250,000 kilocalories for space or water heating in the United States was $5.50 using natural gas, $5.55 using kerosene, $6 using fuel oil, $8 using propane, and $23 using electricity. Whether one fuel costs less than another in a specific application will depend both on how much the energy costs and on the efficiency of the conversion process that is used to convert the energy to the desired end product, in this case heat.
Some schools have saved money by using equipment that could use either oil or natural gas and using that fuel that was least expensive at a given time. Energy cost however is only one of the factors that must be considered in considering which is best in a specific application. Other factors include the cost of the necessary equipment, convenience, safety, environmental impacts and other factors
Energy Units: Developing a common basis for comparison. You probably have already encountered many of the ways energy is measured. The concepts of calorie, Calorie (Kilocalorie), British Thermal Unit (BTU), Therm and Kilowatt Hour all have to do with measuring amounts of energy. Many different units can be encountered when measuring energy use in a school. As an example, Roosevelt High School during January, 1993, made the following energy purchases:
|
Energy Source |
Amount |
Cost |
|
Natural Gas |
4,135.6 Therms |
$2,144.31 |
|
Electricity |
116,399.8 kWH |
$6,563.40 |
|
#5 Fuel Oil |
16,233 Gallons |
$7,308.02 |
|
Total Energy Cost January 1993 |
$16,015.73 |
Make a prediction: From this one month's data (1/12) of a year, what do you think was the total cost of energy at Roosevelt High School?
Why would the month of January not be a good representative month?
To compare the use of different energy sources it is important to know the definitions of the different energy units and how to convert from one to another.
Definitions: (Note: See Table D-1 Auditor Workbook Level I JRB Associates)
Unit __________________________
Kilocalorie (C): Energy needed to Raise 1000 gm water 1o Centigrade (C)
calorie (c): Energy needed to Raise 1 gram water 1o Centigrade (c)
British Thermal Unit (BTU): Energy needed to Raise l pound water 1o Fahrenheit (F)
(about the heat of one lighted wooden match)
Therm: A unit of gas containing 100,000 BTUs
Watt-Hr: The energy in 1 ampere flowing under a voltage of one volt for one hour (3600 joules)
Food Energy: Carbohydrate 1 gm = 4 Cal (1.01 BTU)
Protein 1 gm = 4 Cal (1.01 BTU)
Fat 1 gm = 9 Cal (2.27 BTU)
Conversion Factors: The following factors enable you to convert between different energy units.
*
BTU = 252.5 c or 0.252 C
Kilowatt Hour (KWH) = 3413 BTU
Horsepower-hours = 1.341 KWH
Propane, gallon = 92,500 BTU*
Gasoline, gallon = 125,000 BTU*
Kerosene, gallon = 135,000 BTU*
Diesel oil, gallon = 138,700 BTU*
Fuel Oil, gallon No. 5 = 148, 000 BTU*
How do you compare Therms with Barrels with Kilowatt hours to do a specific task?
Energy Conversion Chart
|
Cubic Feet Natural Gas(CF) |
Barrels Oil (bbl) |
Short Tons Bituminous Coal (T) |
British Thermal Units (Btu) |
Kilowatt Hours Electricity (KWH) |
Bone Dry Douglas Fir Bark & Wood (T) |
|
1000 (1 MCF) |
0.18 |
0.04 |
1 Million |
293 |
0.56 |
|
3,413 |
0.61 |
0.14 |
3.41 Million |
1000 (1 MWH) |
0.19 |
|
1 Million (1 MMCF) |
180 |
40 |
1 Billion |
293,000 |
56 |
Exercise: Convert the Following Energy Units
Calculations:
How many calories (c) in a KWH ? _______________
How many kilocalories(C)
in a KWH? _______________How many calories in a Therm ? _______________
How many kilocalories in a Therm? _______________
How many KWH in a Therm ? _______________
Question: A 200 Watt computer represents how much "horsepower"? ________HP
|
Consultant Question: I just bought a 550 Gallon Hot Tub that I will heat with electricity. I will change my water every three months. How many Calories (Kilocalories) will it take to heat the water ______? How many BTUs ______? How much electricity (KWH) will it take ______? How much will it cost me $$ to heat it ______? Hint: you need the temperature difference of tap water to (40o C). It takes 1C to heat 1000 grams of water 1o so....how many grams and how many degrees? |
Working with conversions helps you understand how to convert from one unit to another. Understanding the price of the units is also important. Converting units may seem hard to do but you already know how to convert dollars into quarters, dimes, nickels and pennies. Energy conversions are similar, except that it is like changing dollars of foreign currency such as pesos (Mexico) or yen (Japan) into American dollars. Similarly, British Thermal Units can be converted into Calories or calories; Kilowatt hours can be converted to BTUs and so forth. For a given time and supplier (price), all of these units can also be converted into dollars ($$).
Investigative Questions:
How much does a KWH cost? ______________(Call your Electric Co.)
How much does a Therm cost? ______________ (Call your Gas company)
How much does a gallon of #5 fuel oil cost? _______________ (Call a local Fuel Co.)
Group Discussion
:

Get together with your team and come up with a list of the factors that you think are important in determining how much energy is needed to run a large building such as your school. In considering factors, think about things that are related to energy use such as outside temperature, locating of the building, what the building is made of, and other features that determine how much electricity, natural gas, and fuel oil it takes to operate your school.
Factors that Influence the Amount of Energy your School Uses
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
_______________________________________________________
As pointed out, in this course you will learn in the context of a real world problem To succeed, you will need to work as a group and have the support of others. Your teacher will be your team coach and assist you in collecting data. However, it is up to you and your team to get the needed information, analyze it, and present your findings. In this process you will need the support of you school's facility managers, teachers, office personnel, fellow students, and equipment and fuel suppliers. Our expectation is that similar teams will be working in other schools throughout Oregon. By communicating with these other efforts, you can compare results and share ideas. Just like a soccer, baseball or football team depends on each player to be good, it is up to you to be a member of the highest scoring energy team.
Let's get started!