Proposed Terms of Service for DSIs
The following comments were submitted in response to the open comment period described below.
Comments are numbered consecutively as they are received. Breaks in the number sequence result when comments are deleted because they
were submitted in error or have inappropriate content (such as SPAM). If you do not see your comment two business days after
you submit it, please contact (800) 622-4519.
BPA issued a letter July 17 regarding service to the aluminum direct-service industries (DSIs) commencing in FY 2010 that indicated BPA is proposing two separate options for the terms of the potential new service.
Columbia Falls Aluminum Company (CFAC) had expressed a desire for a shorter term option that, in return, could provide them a bit more flexibility. However, BPA and CFAC have not been able to agree on principles needed to release a term sheet for a shorter term.
BPA is now proposing only one option for a power sale at the industrial firm power rate that is sufficient to meet a portion of the smelters’ load. The proposed power sales would begin Oct. 1, 2009, and extend through Sept. 30, 2016.
BPA's "Summary of BPA's Use of the Regional Economic Study to Contemplate the Service Concept," which is BPA's update to the results of the "2006 Regional Employment and Economic Study," is available on the Web site below. The update demonstrates a small net gain in jobs from offering the new service constructs to the DSIs compared to the proposal that was under consideration earlier in January 2009.
Comments are numbered consecutively as they are received. Breaks in the number sequence result when comments are deleted because they were submitted in error or have inappropriate content (such as SPAM). If you do not see your comment two business days after you submit it, please contact us at (800) 622-4519.
For More Information:
http://www.bpa.gov/power/pl/regionaldialogue/implementation/documents/
Close of comment: 8/3/2009
- TDS090001 -
Lengerich/SelfTo whom it concerns: Thank you for taking the time to hear feedback from the residents of the Northwest. I moved to the region after college and now after 7 years I consider it a home and a place I can settle due to the vibrant economy and an even better environment/geography. Alcoa Intalco works offered me a position just 2 years ago, and I have thoroughly enjoyed the challenges presented. I thought "after 40 years of making aluminum, what could I possibly bring to the organization that they don't already know - they surely have the process down by now." Certainly I have learned many things about the Aluminum industry, but one of the most impressive is the constant change and drive toward improvement. This is shown in every arena, from cost, to safety, to the environment, and to it's people. This is a facility that is alive because of success in all of these areas - but mostly because of it's people, and it has been a joy to become a part of the team. So this team appreciates the resolution that BPA and Alcoa is working on, and applauds the recognition of this facility as one that brings great benefit to the city, county, and region. The jobs extend futher than the fenceline, and the people that are employeed bring more benefit than the bottom line - they (we) are active in the community and have had an enormous impact on reducing the carbon footprint of the aluminum industry - which has no doubt been pointed out already - and letting these jobs go overseas would certainly be a detriment in so many ways. So please understand that I simply ask BPA to continue to work toward a solution that gives this team the ability to do what we do so well - provide value to region, the community, and the people. We live in an industry that surely will always have ups and downs, but not having a power contract in an aluminum facility puts a stress on employees, families, and the region as a whole - having no idea what the future looks like (for instance...I would love to move closer to work, but with such an uncertain future, my wife and I are very reluctant to make any drastic changs). I simply want to see this facility to continue to improve like it has since long before I joined the team. These jobs are valuable, the people are valuable, and we thank you for a fair, sensible framework that we know will lead to a contract that keeps our facility competitive and thriving. Thank you for your time, Ben Lengerich, P.E. Planning and Reliability Engineering Lead Alcoa Intalco Works
- TDS090002 -
Diehl/SelfThank you for working with Alcoa in developing a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. This agreement is a template for the rest of the country, the private and public sectors can work together in saving jobs, families, homes and communities without a bailout. We cannot ignore the integrated economic value of protecting this NW business. Alcoa has been an integrated part of the NW community for well over 70 years. Intalco’s contribution to the region far exceeds the $190 million in economic benefit to our local and state economy. Intalco’s employees have always take pride in volunteerism, protection of the environment and making Whatcom County one of the best places to live in the Pacific Northwest. Manufacturing jobs have been, and always will be the backbone of our country. We should never allow imported foreign aluminum from Russia, Asia, and the Middle East into the United States. We have gone thru this scenario once before when the Northwest smelters went cold in 2001. Thousands of jobs were lost, families lost their homes and communities never rebounded. This agreement reflects BPA’s original mission statement “To create jobs and stimulate the economies in the rural areas in the Pacific Northwest” Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution, my family, community and this region depends upon it.
- TDS090003 -
/DavisI want to thank you for deciding to give Alcoa a power contract. It relieves alot of stress and puts our minds at ease about our future. We really appreciate your decision and hope that you will continue to provide us with power for many many more years to come! Thank you again Lindsay Davis
- TDS090008 -
/DavisThank you for providing us with power. Your recent decision to provide us with power has put alot of minds at ease and relieves alot of stress from the employees. We hope that you will continue to provide us with power for many many more years! Thank you again Lindsay Davis
- TDS090004 -
/SavilleI want to thank you for all your past support, and for the many years that you have provided for us. The recent proposed contract is a great step for our future here at Alcoa. Please continue to provide our power so that we can keep out jobs. Thanks Mark Saville
- TDS090005 -
NolanThank you for your decision to provide us with power, which also means keeping our jobs. My wife and I just had a baby, and it was very stressful not knowing what the future held. So thank you and please keep providing Alcoa Intalco with power! Thanks Chad Nolan
- TDS090006 -
111Thank you for supporting us with the decidion to provide us with power. My dad and I both work at Alcoa Intalco and were concerned about the future. The seven year power contract has been a stress relief and we want to thank you and ask that you continue to support us for many years to come. Thanks Verle Toby 111
- TDS090007 -
Hay/SelfI want to thank you for the past support and for your recent support with providing us with power. I hope that you will continue to support us in the future as well. Thank you Brandon Hay
- TDS090009 -
Villarreal/selfKeeping Alcoa Intalco jobs is so important to our families and to our community. Thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. Our jobs are very important to our families and to our community. There has been a lot of stress wondering if we were going to keep our jobs, and with this power deal, it has put a lot of our workers minds at ease and in return make us as employees more focused at work. Thank you
- TDS090010 -
RiveraThank you for your past support with providing Alcoa with power. It was a stressful time not knowing what our future held. With your recent support and decision to keep providing Alcoa with power you have put a lot of minds at ease and have made a huge impact on the community. Alcoa provides so many jobs for the community, we really appreciate your decision to keep providing the power for us. Thank you
- TDS090011 -
Rogers/selfWe really appreciate your decision to provide us with power. We also want to thank you for your past support. With the downslide of the economy keeping Alcoa Intalco jobs is crutial for the community. Alcoa Intalco Works brings enormous economic benefit to the local community, state and region. For example, the plant’s annual contribution to GDP is around $190 million. Locally Intalco jobs inject around $60 million into the economy annually, not to mention the economic benefit of the additional 2.9 jobs each Intalco position creates. Thank you
- TDS090012 -
McCauley/SelfWe really appreciate your decision to provide us with power. We also want to thank you for your past support. With the downslide of the economy keeping Alcoa Intalco jobs is crutial for the community. Alcoa Intalco Works brings enormous economic benefit to the local community, state and region. For example, the plant’s annual contribution to GDP is around $190 million. Locally Intalco jobs inject around $60 million into the economy annually, not to mention the economic benefit of the additional 2.9 jobs each Intalco position creates. Thank you
- TDS090013 -
Cavnar/SelfThank you for working with Alcoa Intalco to come to an agreement for a power deal. I have worked out here for about 3 years and it is nice to know that we will have jobs for at least the next seven years. I recently built a house and it gives me a better sence of stability to know that i will be working. So thank you again and please continue providing power for the long term future! thanks Mike Cavnar
- TDS090014 -
Ashe/SelfI am a returning employee, when the plant curtailed the last time, I was laid off. I had the opportunity to come back in 06 and am glad to hear that we will have a power deal for the next seven years. This job is important to me and my family. It gives all us workers peace of mind to know that we will have a job for the next few years. Please continue to support Alcoa Intalco so we can have a long term contract and a more secure future. Thank you again for all your support! Dennis Ashe
- TDS090015 -
Parsons/SelfWe really appreciate your decision to provide us with power. We also want to thank you for your past support. With the downslide of the economy keeping Alcoa Intalco jobs is crutial for the community. Alcoa Intalco Works brings enormous economic benefit to the local community, state and region. For example, the plant’s annual contribution to GDP is around $190 million. Locally Intalco jobs inject around $60 million into the economy annually, not to mention the economic benefit of the additional 2.9 jobs each Intalco position creates. Our community and our families depend on keeping Alcoa Intalco open. Thank you
- TDS090016 -
WassenaarThank you for your continued service to Alcoa Intalco Works. As a 20 year employee I hope to see your continued support for another 30 years. Not only would that be equal to 100 years of BPA providing service to Intalco it would support a new generation of family wage jobs in the Northwest. Our economic times are dependent on saving or creating jobs in our region as we all know the cascading effects of high unemployment rates and job loss. We just want fair power prices so we can compete globally. Thanks for opening this door.
- TDS090093 -
Parker/American Museum of Radio and ElectricityI am writing to thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. This effort is quite meaningful to our community. I am the Executive Director for a local non-profit, the American Museum of Radio and Electricity, that focuses on providing science education to school-age children. Alcoa Intalco Works and their employees have supported this project and our Musuem both financially as well as through gifts of volunteered time and support. The work we are able to do to help prepare and inspire the next generation of creative and scientific thinkers is valuable to our society. In addition they support other important work throughout the community, region and state that will have lasting and meaningful . In fact, Intalco has a strong history of serving this community through charitable contributions, volunteerism and genuine participation in matters of community interest and concern. Furthermore, as a large employer, the negotiation of a continued contract is equally important to the employees and their families that serve Intalco. I encourage your continued work and diligent focus diligence on this matter. We are depending on it. Thank you
- TDS090017 -
Steele/Norpac, Hermiston, and Quincy FoodsNo contracts should be made with DSIs any more. BPA no longer has surplus supply that should be sold at a low price. Surplus supply should be sold into the market at market prices. Doing otherwise (subsidizing DSIs) increases power costs to others, resulting in a net job loss.
- TDS090018 -
Tucker/selfI would like to thank you for your support in the past and the power deal that you have worked with Alcoa Intalco on. We just ask that you will provide us with a long term contract for 15-20 years as well. Alcoa is a 70 year customer that deserves to be treated like every other customer. We are crutial to the community to provide high paying jobs. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract.
- TDS090019 -
WIlliams/selfI have worked at Alcoa Intalco for about 3 years now and and this is the highest paying job that i have ever had. I really enjoy working here and thank you for working with Alcoa on comming to an agreement on a power contract. I really hope that you will provide us with a long term contract so that i can have a secure future. Thanks Jeremy Williams
- TDS090020 -
WalkerIt is unfortunate that our economy is in a recessed condition. Cutbacks and curtaiments are needed to keep existing businesses alive. We as a country need to unite in riding this hardship thru to improved and thriving times. I firmly believe it is in the best interest of our country to assist with the survival of companies that have a history of providing employment for our citizens.Providing power at a rate that will sustain the smelters thru this economic low shows the committment that BPA has for keeping businesses and jobs in our country. Strong leaders will make decisions that are unpopular to some, but the end result will be positive for all.I favor the proposed terms of Service and support BPA in making the committment to provide the needed power.
- TDS090021 -
Parker/American Museum of Radio and ElectricityI am writing to thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. This effort is quite meaningful to our community. I am the Executive Director for a local non-profit, the American Museum of Radio and Electricity, that focuses on providing science education to school-age children. Alcoa Intalco Works and their employees have supported this project and our Museum both financially as well as through gifts of volunteered time and support. The work we are able to do to help prepare and inspire the next generation of creative and scientific thinkers is valuable to our society. Furthermore, this project helps to fill a void in elementary science education, providing an opportunity to get children excited about science at a formative stage in their life. In addition Intalco also supports other important work throughout the community, region and state that will have lasting and meaningful effects for our community and society. In fact, Intalco has a strong history of serving this community through charitable contributions, volunteerism and genuine participation in matters of community interest and concern. Furthermore, as a large employer, the negotiation of a continued contract is equally important to the employees and their families that serve Intalco. I encourage your continued work and diligent focus on this matter. We are depending on it. Thank you Lynne Sherwood Parker Executive Director American Museum of Radio and Electricity 1312 Bay St. Bellingham, WA 98225 (360) 738-3886 Lynne@amre.us
- TDS090022 -
Engler/selfAs a 30 year employee of Intalco I would like to thank B.P.A. for striving to work towards a power contract with Alcoa. In these uncertain time, as unemployment rates continue to rise, it is important that jobs in the Northwest stay in the Northwest. The economic impact of losing an employer like Alcoa would have a ripple effect throughout our community and the outlying areas that would have a negative impact on many. The impact would also go beyond economics as Alcoa and the employees of Intalco have great pride in community service participation, reduction in our environmental footprint, and partnering with our local community on education and social wellbeing. This latest proposal from B.P.A. will serve Alcoa with an IP rate that the 9th circuit court supported and Alcoa needs to be viable in our region. The IP rate and a minimum of a 7 year contract would insure that Alcoa, it't employees and the surrounding community would have a very positive impact on the Northwest for many years to come. Thank you.
- TDS090023 -
Jackson/SelfI am a long time Intalco employee who has a daughter and also a brother–in-law working for Alcoa Intalco Works. Myself and my family would just like to say thank you for working with Alcoa Intalco Works to develop a power contract that will keep our plant operating and my family working for the next seven years. Intalco brings enormous economic benefit to our local community, our state and region. Our jobs inject around $60 million into the economy annually, not to mention the economic benefit of the additional 2.9 jobs each Intalco position creates. Please avoid the temptation to look at service to Alcoa as a ‘cost’. If this test must be applied then one must analyze the cost of service to all BPA customers. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract. The strength of my family and many of my friends depends upon it. Thank You Loren Jackson
- TDS090024 -
DillardI am a seven year Intalco employee and would like to thank BPA for the continued support while working to develop a fair power contract for the northwest region. I feel that this seven year power contract will bring the much needed economic benefits to help stabalize our local communities. With such high unemployment across this region and country and so much uncertainty in everyones minds. This power contract shows that hard work and commitment can bring a positive resolution and relieve the stress on us employees and our family members. Thank you again for your support in drafting this power contract. Mike Dillard
- TDS090025 -
Payne/SelfI honestly believe it is in the best interest of the northwest community as a whole to service the DSIs with power. Intalco's contribution to the region extends well beyond the employement of 500+ family wage jobs. I applaud BPA for working on a 7 year power contract that will provide Intalco an opportunity to operate competitvely. This is a positive step away from outsourcing and towards reinvesting in US manufacturing.
- TDS090026 -
Hullett/SelfDear Administrator Wright: I want to thank your agency for your work in developing the term sheet for potential power service to Alcoa, Intalco Aluminum. As you know, Alcoa has been a customer of BPA for over 50 years and the Intalco site over 40. Aluminum is important to the region and the United States. Providing power to Intalco will avoid job losses and tremendous hardship to the local area and the cascading impact to the region. Intalco partners with the community on many issues and partners with other businesses and even the State of Washington on important initiatives such as Greenhouse gas reduction. Intalco can also play an important role for the region, providing interruptible load, which will help balance new initiatives such as the variable generation rates of wind capacity. Now is the time to act, please continue to work diligently, so a workable contract can be concluded by September. Sincerely, Barry Hullett
- TDS090027 -
Mahala/SelfAlcoa / Intalco has been a long term customer of BPA working with the region on common goals & objectives since the mid 1960's. Alcoa needs this contract to be completed by September in order to maintain a viable business strategy to survive in todays and tomorrows market conditions. Stopping service of Federal power to historical customers like Alcoa/Intalco, and with the current economic crisis we are all facing will be contradictive to providing good jobs and economic growth within our country and state. I ask you to please provide a long term power contract and path for survival for this company "Alcoa". Regards, Marshall Mahala
- TDS090028 -
Smith/SelfI am writing in support of the proposed terms of service for DSIs. With the current economic crisis we are all facing, now is the not the time to stop service of Federal power to historical customers. Alcoa has been a long term customer of BPA, working with the region on common goals and objectives. Now they are facing the possiblity of closing down operations if an agreement cannot soon be reached for providing power at equitable and economic rates. I urge you to complete this conrtact by September. This customer is simply asking is for power rates that are equitable with other customers. It is a matter of fairness, not subsidy.
- TDS090029 -
Vedra/schoolsThank you for for working with Alcoa to keep the Intalco plant,in Whatcom County, on line. As the Superintendent of one of the county school districts, the economic impact of the plant is vital to the City of Bellingham and Whatcom County and our schools. We have many students that directly and indirectly positively benefit from salaries paid the employees at the plant and the money they spend in our area. This contract keeps many people working, at a time when many other businesses in the area are not able to keep people employed. We in the schools have been able to reap another benefit, that benefit is that becasue of our relationship with the company, we have been able to receive science training and additional professional development on the environment, for some of our elementary and middle school staff. The plant sponsored several grants in the distrit which enabled us to train staff and improve curriculum. This is of great benefit to our district and students. Again,thank you for working through this precarious situation with Alcoa and in bringing the seven year contract to fruition. Respectfully, Kenneth D.Vedra, Ed.D. Superintendent of Schools Bellingham School District # 501
- TDS090030 -
Ewing/Ewing's Tree FarmDear BPA: Alcoa Intalco Works is a leader in this community and needs your support in securing a long term power contract. As a local Business owner I feel the pain of the way the economy has brought down so many big name businesses. Intalco supports many of the local charities and non profit organizations and is a big contributer in our school district where budget cuts are the new way of life. Our children deserve the best education they can get and shutting down Intalco will only lead to the destruction of our community. Every one of the Intalco jobs supports 2.9 more jobs locally. They dont want a special stimulus package, just a long term power contract at a fair price. I encourage you to work hard at completing this power contract so the 500 workers at Intalco can get the stability back in their lives. Thank You for your time, Bobby Ewing: President and CEO of Ewing's Tree Farm P.O. Box 5 Custer Wa 98240 360-201-6037
- TDS090031 -
Gollen/Alcoa IntalcoI am a second generation Alcoan and have worked at Alcoa Intalco for over 14 years. My father worked here for over 30 years and retired from Alcoa. I am 40 years old and still have a long way to retirement. My wife just had my first baby in May. A power contract would help my family and our community get through these tough finacial times. Please consider the impact a power contract would be on our community. Thank you, Bill Gollen
- TDS090032 -
VasakAcoa Intalco Works brings enormous economic benefit to the local community, state and region. For example, the plant’s annual contribution to GDP is around $190 million. Intalco’s contribution to the region extends beyond economic benefit. Intalco has a strong history of serving this community through charitable contributions, volunteerism and genuine participation in matters of community interest and concern.
- TDS090033 -
Brown/Alcoa Intalco WorksComment: I would like to take the time to thank BPA for the time and consideration given to the Intalco Smelter in regard to a new power contract. As a 3 year employee, living in a county with an unemployment rate that continues to rise, it is very important to me and my family that this power contract is secured. As an Intalco employee I take pride in my work and my company. Alcoa Intalco Works brings enormous economic benefit to the loca! l community, state and region. For example, the plant's annual! contrib ution to GDP is around $190 million. Also, Intalco jobs inject around $60 million into the economy annually, not to mention the economic benefit of the additional 2.9 jobs each Intalco position creates. One cannot ignore the integrated economic value of protecting this NW business. Intalco's contribution to the region extends beyond economic benefit. As individuals and an organization, we take pride in partnering with the community on common goals and objectives whether they are in the area of environment, education or social wellbeing. Our partnerships come through reductions to our environmental footprint, financial contributions, participation in community boards and taskforces and volunteerism. We have been a long term customer of BPA working with the region on common goals & objectives. We need this contract to be completed by September. Now is not the time to stop service of Federal power to historical customers, with the current economic crisis we are all facing. The ! vast majorities of Intalco's customers is located on the West Coast of North America and currently include manufacturers in Washington and Oregon. If Intalco shuts down, our customers would likely be supplied by imported foreign aluminum from Russia, Asia, and the Middle East. As has been witnessed in the past when NW smelters were curtailed, foreign sources that achieve 100% market share for the Western US have the ability to dramatically raise premium pricing, putting the customers of Intalco aluminum at risk of survival. I would like to remind you that this is fundamentally a question of fairness. BPA's mission states that its role is to serve power and deliver value to NW customers and constituents. Alcoa is a 70 year customer that deserves to be treated like every other customer. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract. The strength of my family, my community and this region depends upon it. Sincerely, Jennifer Brown
- TDS090034 -
Flaherty/IAMAWSteve Wright, Allen Burns and Staff- I would like to take this opportunity to “Thank You All” for the time and effort you have given to working with Alcoa towards the development of the post 2009 Power contract. This will give Alcoa Intalco Works hope of continued operation for at least the next seven years. That being said, I am still a little disappointed that an agreement couldn’t have been worked out for the 10-17 year contract that was initially anticipated. For years we have been asking that Alcoa Intalco Works be treated the same as other industrial customers, that receive BPA power. With the proposed contract at IP rate, we are still going to be paying more than 20% higher rates than the other industrial customers. The IP rate for Intalco is not special treatment for us, in fact it could be said that we are actually subsidizing the other customers by paying this higher rate. Alcoa has been a customer of BPA for more than 70 years and needs to be treated as such, not pushed aside and abandon. Who would be next? Over the past years there have been numerous Economic Studies that have been submitted by different groups (including Alcoa) that show what kind of impact various scenario’s would have on different regions on the Pacific NW. Our opposition often states/speculates, that by servicing Alcoa Intalco, they might see job lose in their regions. The fact is if this contract doesn’t come to reality you will be able to point directly to Intalco and say that was 500+ jobs (an additional 1500 +/- indirect jobs) we could have saved. Our long time customers (including SAPA in Portland) would be forced to purchase their goods off shore and that would almost assuredly affect their bottom line, their employment numbers and potentially their survival. It is very important to our NW community, the employees and families as well as our customers that this contract be finalized by October 1st. That BPA makes every effort to secure power for the final 5 years of this seven years deal as soon as possible. The sooner the better as current prices would have less impact on all BPA customers than previously projected. Again, thank you for your time and efforts. Respectively Pat Flaherty
- TDS090035 -
Sherwood/IndividualTo whom it may concern. Woven into the fabric of North West business interests are representations of the many years of service that Alcoa Intalco Works has benefitted from and consequently from which many other businesses, public, private entities, have also benefitted because of Alcoa’s continued operations in the region. It seems to me the DSI’s, smelters; Alcoa, have the same interests as other entities in the region; a reasonable chance to survive. Each concern regardles of its scope; private, public, commerce, industry, farms, or residences served by public utilities, cooperatives or IOU’s have common goals and objectives. The failure of one will not substationally benefit the other. The pursuit of and the effort to work in collaboration towards the general success of the regions economy supports all other interests.It is an effort which is a sound business principle and is in BPA’s as well as the regions best interest. Sale of power to the DSI’s makes a positive step in the direction of the common good of the region. Please don’t delay or be mis-directed by a narrow vision of the future. Now if any is the time to put our shoulder to the wheel and make all effort to get the economy moving in a favorable direction. I commend and encourage those who are in a position to make a difference to do so, with the widest possible benefit as a common goal. Thank you for the opportunity to comment.
- TDS090036 -
Broyan/blaine,wa.I have worked for Intalco for over 40 yrs. We have purchased all of our house hold goods in this area. Revinue from these sales has kept many people employed. Without us, no money, no worky, no life...We need this contract to keep our economy afloat.Please make this contract worthwhile for all concerned. Thank You Mr.Carl Broyan
- TDS090037 -
Mitchell/Alcoa Intalco WorksPower issues in the NW region of the United States are not easy to resolve. At this time, it seems like someone will lose and that there cannot be 100% winners in the allotment. I would not want to be the one to make such decisions. That being said, I would like to cast my vote for Intalco. I am biased being that I work there. I need my job to survive and keep my home. Because of the current economic situation in the building industry, my wife's paint shop business has been forced to close. This has put us right on the edge. Another economic hit will put us over. I would like to ask that Intalco be given a chance to buy power at a fair and reasonable price and that a contract be signed by September. Thank You.
- TDS090038 -
Rothenbuhler/IntalcoIntalco injects more than $60 million into our community through payroll, contributions, taxes and contracts. With an equitable power contract, Intalco could once again operate at full capacity of up to 1200 employees. Your support in winning an equitable power contract would double, if not more, our contribution to the infrastructure of the state, county and local economy through payroll, contributions, taxes and contracts. I am urging you to take action to protect our local and state stability by sustaining our work force Thanks for your support!
- TDS090039 -
Ratcliff/SelfDear Mr. Wright and Staff, Please let me take this opportunity to thank you for working with Alcoa to provide us with a power contract for at least seven years. I’ve been an employee here at Intalco for over 35 years and was not looking forward to having to go out and find a new job in a county that already has very high unemployment rates. My wife and I will breathe a little easier when this whole process is over and done. Alcoa Intalco Works contributes 500+ jobs here at the plant, but as I know you’ve all heard before there are many other jobs in the county that are indirectly tied to us too. I believe I’ve heard the jobs here have been said to inject around $60 million into our county’s economy. Intalco’s contribution to the community is not just economic. I and many of my fellow workers volunteer our time for numerous organizations. We can do that because we have good family wage jobs and don’t have to work other part time jobs to keep the bills paid. We can spend time working for the Boys & Girls Club in Ferndale, the Boy Scouts of America, numerous church groups, or in my case the American Cancer Society’s – Relay for Life to name just a few. I would also like to address the fact that I could never understand why you could arbitrarily just decide that you were not going to service one customer when you decided not to service the DSI’s. We have been paying customers for decades and I feel that it’s only fair that you put us in the equation when you figure out how much power the region is going to need and then spread the cost out among everyone. If we are deemed to be expendable, then whose next when you need to go out and get even more power for the region. The 9th circuit ruled that you have the right to serve us and I am grateful that you have added us back into the mix at the IP rate. This rate gives my plant a reasonable chance at survival. We have done everything we can at the plant to bring our costs down. With a minimum of a seven year contract and enough power to run two potlines we should be able to make the plant profitable when this economy finally turns around. In conclusion please just let me say thank you again. As a 54 year old I’m not sure what kind of options I would be looking at if I was pushed out onto the street looking for a new job. Seven years will get me closer to retirement and then if we can figure out a way to get five or ten more the younger employees that work here would have the same opportunity that I’ve had. Again, thank you very much for all you’ve done. Sincerely, Carl Ratcliff 35 year Intalco Employee
- TDS090040 -
KamionkaPlease accept my strong encouragement to continue working with Alcoa Intalco Works to come to a mutually agreeable power contract. Intalco not only provides a significant economic impact on the region, but the community spirit demonstrated by the staff and families of Intalco is felt throughout the area. The same passion and resilience with which the leadership negotiates with BPA is present in all of the staff as they participate in enriching the quality of life in the area. As a member of the Board of the Museum of Radio & Electricity, the financial and volunteer support of Intalco not only provides opportunities for children to experience the wonders of science but also the impact of great corporate citizenship. It seems only fair and just to provide them with the power they require and deserve to continue this economic and community success.
- TDS090041 -
Morgan/SelfI am a 21 year employee at Alcoa Intalco Works and I would like to thank you for working with us on a new power contract. With the world and local economy still struggling to recover now it is more important then ever to save local jobs. Intalco injects over 60 million dollars into the economy annually. A majority of Intalco’s customers are located on the west coast, including manufactures in Washington and Oregon. Intalco’s benefits reach beyond economics. Our employees donate several thousands of hours a year to local charities and organizations. Without this 7 year contract at IP rate and enough power to run 2 potlines this region will lose more then family wage earning jobs, it will lose families. My family and community depends on this contract. Thank you again for your continued efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution. Scott Morgan
- TDS090042 -
Swendt/selfthank you BPA for your continued support while working to develop a fair power contract for the northwest region. I feel that this seven year power contract will bring the much needed economic benefits to help stabalize our local communities. Thank you for working with Alcoa Intalco on this contract and please keep providing for us for many more years to come. Thank you Jason Swendt
- TDS090043 -
Siedschlag/selfThank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. This is such a great help to our community. It provides family wage jobs in our region, and with the unemployment rates growing, it is so important to keep Alcoa Intalco open and provide jobs for our community members. Continued support for longer than 15-20 years would ensure family wage jobs in our region. Thank you Connie Siedschlag
- TDS090044 -
McDonald/SelfThank you for the time and effort you have given to working with Alcoa towards the development of the power contract. This will give all employees at Alcoa Intalco Works hope of continued operation for at least the next seven years. Alcoa has been a customer of BPA for more than 70 years and we hope to see your continued support for another 30 years. Not only would that be equal to 100 years of BPA providing service to Intalco it would support a new generation of family wage jobs in the Northwest. Thanks Doug McDonald
- TDS090045 -
Flammang/SelfIt is very important to our NW community, the employees and families as well as our customers that this contract be finalized by October 1st. I thank you for your past support and hope that you continue to support Alcoa Intalco, and provide a long term contract for the next 15-20 years so that Alcoa can continue to provide family wage jobs for the next generation. Thank you Ken Flammang
- TDS090046 -
Morris/SelfFirst off thank you for suporting us for so many years, and thank you for working with Alcoa Intalco to come up with a seven year power contract. We have had a lot of stress on the job not knowing what the future held. I hope that we can come to an agreement and recieve a long term power contract. Alcoa Intalco is a family wage job and it provides for alot of families in our community. Thank you Ron Morris
- TDS090047 -
Carampot/selfAs a 3yrs employee,I would like to thank you for devoloping a power contract for Intalco for the next seven years.Intalco's continous operation brings enormous benefits to my family,community,state and the whole region.BPA's mission state that it's role is to serve power and deliver value to NW customers and constituents.Alcoa is a 70yrs customer that deserves to be treated like every other customer.Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through a seven year power contract.
- TDS090048 -
Engler/SelfI would like to thank B.P.A. for working towards a power contract with Alcoa Intalco. In these uncertain time, as unemployment rates continue to rise, it is important that jobs in the Northwest stay in the Northwest. Thank you Don Engler
- TDS090049 -
No comment attached.
- TDS090050 -
Carampot/the Carampot FamilyI would like to take this opportunity to thank BPA in anticipation of its completion of the work done with Alcoa Intalco to secure a mutually beneficial arrangement for the next seven years with hopes that a longer agreement will be reached during that timeframe. Alcoa is important to our community and families, both for its jobs and its support of community events and services. Thank you, BPA, for your historical support of this industry and the families and communities it supports.
- TDS090051 -
Allen/Laughing Rabbit IncorporatedOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. We are having a hard enough time keeping the business doors open without the spectre of increased power rates. Sincerely, David Allen President: LRI
- TDS090052 -
benson/selfBPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us, the private end user.
- TDS090053 -
Koontz/my familyOur community's businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I'm writing to let you know that BPA's proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community's dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. I suspect you'll do whatever you want, but this is how a lot of people feel about this proposal. Robin Koontz Blachly Lane Electric Co-op customer since 1979
- TDS090054 -
Lemer/my family of 5Our community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Act in the best interests of your homeowner subscribers, and don't raise our rates while giving 'sweetheart deals' to industry. Make the industrial users gaining profit from their activities pay more. Not us!
- TDS090092 -
BurmeisterDear Sir: Our community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Helen Burmeister
- TDS090055 -
StanfieldAs a private citizen purchasing power through our electric coop Blachley Lane, I do not believe it to be sound public policy or even good buisness practice to subsidize ALCOA and Glencore on the backs of the people you serve. In these trying times, small buisness and the general public deserve to have the same pricing structure that big buisness entities such as these have, not higher rates in order to subsidize their low rates for the terms of their negotiated contracts with you. Thanks for tor concideration and time.
- TDS090056 -
Kennedy/my familyI’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090091 -
ApplegatePlease do not subsidize aluminum plants at my expense. WE are paying an obscene amount already to "save" the salmon.
- TDS090057 -
Kimbley/SelfThank you BPA for the continued support while working to develop a fair power contract for Alcoa Intalco works. I feel that this seven year power contract will bring the much needed economic benefits to help stabalize our local communities. Alcoa Intalco provides 500+ jobs and also helps with community service projects. We hope that you will continue to support us to reach a long term contract for the next 15-20 years to continue to provide for the next generations and their families. Thank you Levi Kimbley
- TDS090094 -
Please do not subsidize aluminum smelters at the expense of Coop electricity users. Thank you Jon Doornink
- TDS090085 -
Doornink/Blachly-Lane Coop membershipOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Jon Doornink Member, Blachly-Lane Electric Co-op
- TDS090058 -
Larson/SelfThank you for working with Alcoa in developing a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. During this tough economic time, not knowing if we are going to have a job has put alot of stress on us as employees and put alot of stress on our families. We have gone thru this scenario once before when the Northwest smelters went cold in 2001. Thousands of jobs were lost, families lost their homes and communities never rebounded. Please secure our jobs so we can have peace of mind and continue providing for our future. Thank you Daren Larson
- TDS090059 -
Pilkey/SelfI want to thank you for working so hard with Alcoa Intalco to some up with a seven year power agreement. Alcoa has been an integrated part of the NW community for well over 70 years. And we hope to continue to operate for many more years to come. Intalco’s contribution to the region far exceeds the $190 million in economic benefit to our local and state economy. We are also very involved in supporting our community with volunteer work. Thank you Dan Pilkey
- TDS090060 -
Brauer/selfOur community’s citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is not a good idea. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our citizens. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. I am asking that you not proceed with BPA's proposal. Sincerely yours, Aen Brauer
- TDS090061 -
Isakson/SelfThis agreement reflects BPA’s original mission statement “To create jobs and stimulate the economies in the rural areas in the Pacific Northwest” Thank you for all your support and continue to provide for us so that we can continue to provide jobs to our communities. Thanks again
- TDS090062 -
Brabham/selfOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Please reconsider this decision. Sue Brabham
- TDS090090 -
StephensOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090063 -
NicholsI am concerned about spending 1/2 billion dollars to help Alcoa and Glencore without a contract that guarantees the investment will be fully repaid. If they don't pay the cost, other rate payers will. This does not make economic sense.
- TDS090064 -
Anderson/SelfBPA has provided power to Alcoa Intalco for 70 years and in return has provided many jobs for our community. This job has provided for my family and now is providing for my sons family. I hope that you will continue to provide power to Alcoa Intalco for a long term power contract. Thank you for all your support.
- TDS090088 -
Myers/Public payorOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. I am appalled at the business principles you espouse. If I did this in my profession I would be criminalized. Larry Myers MD
- TDS090086 -
FinleyOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BONNEVILLE POWER ADMINISTRATION’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BONNEVILLE POWER AADMINISTRATION is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BONNEVILLE POWER ADMINISTRATION should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Jack R. Finley
- TDS090087 -
Lenmark/Blachly LaneAs a consumer I urgently oppose this action. This is not the time for more problems...not now or ever. Jolene Lenmark Our community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Bud Tracy General Manager tracyb@blachlylane.coop
- TDS090065 -
Adams/Blachly LaneCo-op power purchaserOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Personal note: This move seems eerily similar to the power moves employed by Enron which devastated California! Where are your ethics?
- TDS090066 -
CPA/SelfThe time when we had substantial surplus power are history and the practice of serving the DSI's needs to be history as well. Oregon is facing a huge financial crisis as is Springfield and Lane County with a constantly rising demand for increasing revenue for government services. To be hit with increased utility costs with no increase in benefit is hurting my business as well as the businesses of my clients. This is unacceptable to me just to continue the archaic practice of subsidizing the DSI's. Thank you Mike T
- TDS090067 -
WaggonerBPA, thank you for working with Alcoa to bring affordable power to Intalco. Intalco supplies over 500 "LIVING" wage jobs to Whatcom county. Thanks
- TDS090068 -
Faubion/Citizens in City of EllensburgOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Ben Faubion (509) 962-1545 2302 Ellington St. Ellensburg, WA 98926
- TDS090069 -
Clair/SelfAs a current employee of Alcoa Intalco Works, I am writing in support of the proposed terms of service for DSIs. Thank you for the time and effort spent working to develop the term sheet for power service to Intalco. Alcoa Intalco Works has been a long term customer of BPA, working with the region on common goals and objectives. With the current economic crisis we are all facing, now is the not the time to stop service of Federal power to historical customers. The contract will finally ensure a piece of security for Intalco employees and those we rub shoulders with every day within the community. Please complete this contract by September in order to secure jobs in our community.
- TDS090070 -
Craig/SelfAs of this writing there were 36 comments on the Proposed Terms of Service for DSIs -- The vast majority of these comments appear to be from employees of Alcoa, Inc. and are supportive. -- The "OTHER SIDE OF THE STORY" involves private citizens like ourselves who will be saddled with sky-rocketing power costs as a result of this subsidy. BPA should not use our community dollars to benefit private companies. Particularly those in the aluminum smelting business. Remember the Kaiser Aluminum fiasco ??? Kaiser made millions and our power rates doubled !!!!!
- TDS090071 -
Jacksch/Blachly Lane Electric Co-opOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090072 -
StearnsMy community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I believe that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA will cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that, in effect, taxes the citizens of our community to benefit private companies. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Katharine Stearns
- TDS090073 -
McFaddenDear BPA: Our economy in Lane County is hurting with unemployment at over 10%. Wood products firms have cut back and some have shut down. How you can offer Alcoa a subsidized electric rate at the expense of other businesses and homeowners in the region is beyond comprehension. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090074 -
Allen/Blachly-Lane Co-OpOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090075 -
Stoppel/FamilyIn these tough economic times, BPA's proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers if very poor public policy, and BPA's willingness to cover the risk of their walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us, increasing power rates we pay which will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090076 -
/BrumetHere we are again, trying to save jobs and preserve the services Alcoa/Intalco Works in Ferndale, Washington. This business has been a valuable employer in our community for years and supports not only many families with good wage paying jobs but many community groups as well. This is not the time to discontinue Federal power to historical customers especially in light of the economic struggles all of America is facing. Let's allow these people to know their jobs are intact for many years to come.
- TDS090077 -
Knelly/selfOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090089 -
MacClary/Blachly LaneOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090078 -
Rasmussen/self and fellow membersOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090079 -
Olson/SelfMr. Wright, I want to thank you and BPA for working with Alcoa Intalco Works for a seven year power contract. Our jobs inject around $60 million into the economy annually. We also help create another 2.9 jobs. The volunteerism from Intalco into the community is second to none. Thank you again for your hard work and a swift resolution. Jim Olson
- TDS090080 -
WeisenburgerDear Mr. Wright, Once again I would like to thank your proposed agreement with ALCOA for the continued operation of the Intalco smelter.I realize a lot of the northwest P.U.D.s resent the aluminum industry getting what they feel is a bail out of the industry. I believe that this is no time for losing more jobs in northwest Washington. We also hope for a long term solution for power in our plant. We have had a long history with the BPA and hope to continue to. Thank you, Ken weisenburger, 37 years as an hourly employee with Intalco
- TDS090081 -
/myselfI would like to express my concern about the monitary loss that BPA would be making and the fact that they have announced roughly a 20% increase in the rate in my area. Also, if these companies back out of this the loss is put on the general public's shoulders. Our community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses.
- TDS090082 -
Lemler/myselfOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090083 -
Knauft/SelfTo Whom It May Concern: Thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. I have worked at Alcoa Intalco for over 25 years, so a long-term power contract is vital for my family, and numerous families throughout the area. Without affordable power, it would be difficult to plan for our family’s future. One cannot ignore the integrated economic value of protecting this NW business. The vast majorities of Intalco’s customers are located on the West Coast of North America and currently include manufacturers in Washington and Oregon. I hope you can understand what it means to me, my family, and numerous people that depend on Alcoa Intalco Works for jobs and community structure. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract. The strength of my family, my community and this region depends upon it. Sincerely, Charles Knauft IV
- TDS090084 -
Chartier/senior citizensIf BPA were going to subsidize a green energy project, I would be willing for my costs to increase a little to help the country, and, yes, I know BPA sells hydropower, not coal power. It is NOT in the best interests of all parties to subsidize a private company at potentially large costs to its other customers. I live in a rural community served by an electric co-op. I already pay higher rates than nearby Eugene, Oregon, and do not want to see my rates increase again to subsidize an aluminum plant. Subsidies, if they must be given, should be strictly regulated, have short time frames, and pose no risk to people who have no choice but pay higher costs or choose between eating, medicating or freezing in winter.
- TDS090095 -
Umbaugh/SelfTo whom it may concern, Thank you for working so hard at coming to a possible agreement with Alcoa Intalco Works for a power contract. Intalco has been a well respected member of the community for over 40 years. It's survival has been right on the edge for years now. Not because of it's performance, but because of the cost of power. Even with the proposed rates , Intalco will still pay more than practically any other smelter in the system, both US and across the world. However, the proposal will enable Intalco to survive. In this time of accelerated unemployement it is a positive testament to those at BPA that they are recognizing the impact of Intalco closing on the community, the employee's, and the families of the employee's. Once again thank you for your efforts in reaching this agreement.
- TDS090096 -
Lem/Blachly Lane Coopur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. B & L Lem
- TDS090097 -
I believe that I and my fellow citizens should not have to pay for an aluminum smelter bills. Aluminum should not be subsidized, It is one of the most energy intensive processes, and it is also toxic. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to difficulties for our region.
- TDS090098 -
Emerson/My familyThank you for the progress that has been made by agreeing to a terms sheet. However the job is not done yet. As I look at the broad picture of supply to Public Utilities and the DSI's I see disparities that I believe are unfair and should be taken into consideration as final contract negotiations are completed. Aside from price, the 7 year term is a severe constraint on a capital intensive business. In addition having the very provision of power linked to market power rates, places an unfair burden on Intalco that should be shared by all consumers. Finally to not take into account the historical load (and revenues) that Intalco provided seems fundamentally unfair. In closing I ask that BPA completes a contract for the supply of at least 320 MW for at least 20 years.
- TDS090099 -
Higman/SelfI have worked for 13 years at Alcoa Intalco Works and I would like to take the time to thank you for working with us on a new power contract. Intalco helps with over 60 million dollars into the economy annually. A majority of Intalco’s customers are located on the west coast, including manufactures in Washington and Oregon. Alcoa Intalco Works has provided sponsor ships for schools, Boys and Girls clubs and other charity events. Without this 7 year contract at IP rate and enough power to run 2 potlines this region will lose more than family wage earning jobs, it will lose families and small local businesses . My family, friends and community depends on this aluminum smelter running. Thank you again for your time and continued efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution. Ernie Higman
- TDS090100 -
MyersThank you for your efforts to work with Alcoa Intalco Works to develop a power contract that will allow the plan to continue operating for at least the next 7 years. Alcoa is a key employer and community partner in Whatcom County and we hope to see the smelter continue to operate for many years to come. Best of luck with the negotiation and please know that thousands of people in Whatcom County are grateful for your good faith efforts.
- TDS090101 -
Lentz/selfThank you for taking time to consider setting detail to a power sales and transmission proposal for the DSI group, with enough power to operate at capicity for a longer duration we would be able to expect reinvestment that could give us global competitive capability. this at least gives a fighting chance at reaching that day. Please continue to work with folks here in the Northwest to come to reasonable solution for all of us. we all have a lot at stake trying to maintain this environment and every improvement that can be implemented helps. Thanks again and please continue to work at the finding the best solution for everyone in our region. Jerry
- TDS090102 -
Shannon/Alcoa Intalco WorksAs a 3 year employee I thank B.P.A. for working with Alcoa on developing a power contract that will keep this plant operating. With the unemployment rate rising in Washington every bit helps, as Intalco alone injects 60 million a year into the local economy. The plant brings enormous economic benefit with an annual contribution to the GDP of 190 million. hank you for your efforts on bringing this to a resolution, with the provision of a 7 year contract. Thank you, Justin Shannon
- TDS090114 -
WEST/MY FAMILYI AM A 30 PLUS YEAR EMPLOYEE WORKING AS A MILLWRIGHT FOR INTALCO. EACH DAY I COME TO WORK I DON'T FEEL I AM WORKING FOR THE GIANT ALCOA BUT FOR THE PEOPLE IN THE AREA I'M IN. I WORK FOR VERY GOOD PEOPLE IN PRODUCTION & WITH VREY GOOD PEOPLE IN THE CRAFTS. WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH THE RINGER ON WORRYING ABOUT THE POWER CONTRACTS TO TRYING TO SQUEEZE OUT EVRY CENT OF INIFICIANCY WE CAN TO MAKE IT THOUGH THIS TRIAL. IF YOU COULD SEE THE EXTRA EFFORT FROM THESE PEOPLE YOU BE AMAZED.TALKING TO PEOPLE OUT HERE WE GRUMBLE A BIT, BUT SEEM TO RISE TO THE TASK EVERY TIME. AND WHAT'S NOTICABLE NOW IS THAT WE ARE VERY THANKFUL TO HAVE A GOOD JOB. WE DO MAKE A WAGE WE CAN RAISE A FAMILY ON, WE DO AN AMAZING AMOUNT OF GIVING TO COMMUNTY CHARITIES, FAR MORE THAN ANYONE HEAR'S ABOUT & WE DO SUPPORT THE COMMUNITY BUSSINESS. IT SEEMS THAT IT'S A WIN WIN WIN DEAL WHEN THIS CONTRACT IS SIGNED. AND WHEN IT IS YOU WILL HAVE THE THANKS MY FAMILY, MY CO-WORKERS OUR COMUNITY & ME FROM THE BOTTOM OF MY HEART. AT THIS TIME WE SURELY NEED TO KEEP GOOD PAYING JOBS GOING. THANKYOU FOR LISTENING
- TDS090103 -
ThiessenThank you for all the hard work & effort you have put into developing a power contract that would provide Intalco with the opportunity to operate for the next 7 years. At a time of rising unemployment, the jobs that Alcoa provides in this community are more important now than ever, especially when you consider the economic benefit of the additional 2.9 jobs that each Intalco position creates. It is imperative to the employees, their families and the local community that a power contact is secured.
- TDS090104 -
Wiegand/SelfTo Whom It May Concern: Thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate. My hope was always to continue to work and live in the community I have cherished my entire lifetime. I have worked at Alcoa Intalco for over 21 years and reaching an agreement for a long term power contract is vital not only for my family but numerous families throughout the area. Without an affordable power contract in place it is difficult to plan for the future; not only as an active community member supporting other local businesses, but to remain living and working in the area. There is also the matter of the economic value of Alcoa Intalco that reaches beyond our immediate community. A good portion of our customers are located on the West Coast including Washington, Oregon, Idaho, California, and across the border into Canada. We use local truck carriers out of the west coast (as well as national) along with BNSF Railway, Intermodal, and ship(both Port of Seattle and Tacoma) to transport product. We use many local shops to rebuild or fabricate parts and supplies, and have many suppliers, some with local warehouses, in support of inventoried materials. The list of supporting efforts not only in our community, but along the west coast and beyond is endless; all which would be affected without the support of this power agreement. It is my hope that we do not have to experience firsthand the implications of what it would mean to not have a power agreement in place. I would like to thank again all the people diligently working for a resolution to our power issue. Your efforts have not gone unnoticed and are truly appreciated. Sincerely; Ann Wiegand
- TDS090105 -
Johnson/IntalcoThank you for your efforts working with Alcoa to attain a fair power contract for our Intalco plant. I have worked in this industry for over 30 years and have seen many Northwest aluminium plants close over the years due to high energy prices. With a fair power contract our plant will again be competitive in a globle market and protect valuable jobs in our community. Thank you again. Tracy Johnson
- TDS090106 -
Coning/SelfTo our respected officials at BPA: I appreciate the good work that has been done to date to develop a Term Sheet to ensure that Alcoa can potentially continue to operate in the Northwest. Thank you for honoring a long term customer and providing Alcoa with the opportunity to deliver growth and value back into the region. Whilst this forum is likely not intended to be a debating blog, I would like to articulate the benefits of producing aluminum in the Northwest: (1)Aluminum production will continue throughout the world, with or without Intalco. By producing it in the US, we can ensure that we adhere to the strict environmental policies and regulations which could easily be sacrificed in other parts of the world. We are all Ambassadors of this planet and through manufacturing of this commodity under 1st world standards, we ensure that we create a positive future for next generations. (2)The downstream aluminum industry will continue to produce products for the US automotive, construction and transport markets. Many smelters across the US have already closed their doors forcing the downstream industry to purchase their product outside the US. By moving ahead with this contract, you will not only secure 500+ jobs at Intalco, but ensure that the US aluminum industry remains healthy and continue to contribute to the GDP of this country. (3)I have no doubt that the demand for power will increase over time. The benefit of having a large consumer on standby to distribute a portion of its load into the grid to avoid impact on critical services such as medical care is priceless. Thank you again for allowing the public to comment on this. I believe this is a win-win situation for the region, our country and even humankind.
- TDS090107 -
leach/selfThank you Mr. Wright for all your efforts in helping us secure our extended power contract. As a 21 yr. employee of Intalco it is a great relief to know I have some job security for myself and family for at least the next seven years. Hopefully much longer!
- TDS090117 -
curtright/alcoa intalco worksplease save our jobs thanks
- TDS090108 -
Downing/selfI would like to say thank you for working with Alcoa to lock down a power contract at the Intalco plant. The news of this is a relief to me and my family. Briging a sence of closure to the uncertianty of my emoloyement at this plant. I cant thank you enough. Brian
- TDS090109 -
Diehl/MyselfI would like to take the time to thank the BPA for working with Alcoa in getting the power contract at Intalco finalized. The news of this brings a huge deal relief to me and my family. It is nice to know that I can continue working for the timebeing
- TDS090110 -
WickBPA: Our community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. More so, if you remember the founding stipulation of the Bonneville Project Act, "The Act stipulated that the new power agency would market and transmit power from federal dams and “... give preference and priority in the use of electric energy to public bodies and cooperatives.” This proposed sale is especially infuriating when we have supported BPA over the years by opposing legislation that was detrimental to the agency and some that ultimately would put BPA out of business. Your sales staff is harming your oldest and most supportive customers, the private consumers, in an effort to make a "big sale" that will look good on your financial statements in the short term. Considering that there will never be a lack of demand for your product, there is no reason to make sales such as these that would harm multitudes and benefit a few. Please remember your roots and reconsider your proposal.
- TDS090111 -
Allen/SelfTo whom it may concern. I would like to thank BPA for working so hard and diligently on this current power contract with Alcoa Intalco Works. Its very importand we keep people employed during these tough economic times. Alcoa has been a long standing costomer for over 50 years and deserves a fair contract so once again thank you.
- TDS090112 -
Burke/SelfThank for giving Alcoa Intalco the opportunity to survive. I am a third generation intalco employee. And hope to see it run for decades to come. This is a big help not only to the plant but to the surrounding community and county.
- TDS090113 -
Fitzgerald/SelfDear BPA, I have been employed in the aluminum industry since October 1978. Employment at Intalco has allowed me to raise my family, send my children to college, and donate to the community. I now have grandchildren living in the NW that may look to Alcoa for a career in the coming years. For these and many other reasons, I would like to thank BPA for the work on the term sheet for a 7 year power contract with Alcoa Intalco Works. This is quite a relief for the workers, as well as, the community. This is a great investment and will play its part in the economic recovery. Preserving 500 jobs in the NW is certainly part of the equation. Without this power agreement, the loss of jobs in the community would be devastating, not to mention the loss of the 500 jobs at Intalco. We have a long standing partnership and we look forward to continuing this over the next 7 years and well beyond. We have managed to figure it out for the last 40 years, let go for another 40! Please direct your focus targeting a very quick resolution. Sincerely, Mel Fitzgerald
- TDS090115 -
Nguyen/SelfTo whom it may concern, As a 19 year employee, it is very important to me and my family that this power contract is secured. Thank you very much for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for the next seven years. Alcoa Intalco Works brings economic benefit to the local community, state and region. Most of Intalco’s customers are located on the West Coast of North America and currently include manufacturers in Washington and Oregon. Intalco’s contribution to the region extends beyond economic benefit. This is fundamentally a question of fairness because BPA’s mission states that its role is to serve power and deliver value to NW customers and constituents. Alcoa is a 70 year customer that deserves to be treated like every other customer. The 9th circuit court ruled that BPA has the right to serve Alcoa power at the IP rate and the proposed contract framework applies that IP rate. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract.
- TDS090116 -
Cooper/SelfThis job means alot to my family and I. I have numerous family members that work out here and depend on Alcoa Intalco to stay open. I thank you for providing power for the past seventy years and hope that you will make us a long term customer. My family and I depend on it. Thank you Cheyanne Cooper
- TDS090118 -
Cain/Self and FamilyTo Stephen Wright & the staff at BPA: Thank you for continuing to work with Alcoa on the much needed power deal. In these uncertain economic times, it is reassuring to know that you are committed to preserving family wage jobs in this region. Many families face financial crisis right now, stopping the service to a long time customer, and major employer would serve to exacerbate that crisis and would seem to be contrary to the Federal government’s objectives at this time. Knowing that Alcoa has a power deal in place and that my family and I can make plans for the future will help relieve much of the uncertainty, so it is important that an agreement we reached as soon as possible, hopefully by September. Alcoa has demonstrated its commitment to this region by hanging on and preserving local jobs through tough times. If BPA serves Intalco power at rates comparable to other Northwest customers, we can save these jobs, and maybe create new ones. On the other hand, jobs that are lost now may never come back, so we need to translate the long standing past relationship between Alcoa and BPA into a long standing future relationship. It is true that our community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. Alcoa’s continuing presence enriches the community, loss of this presence will benefit no one, not even the customers of the various PUD’s. I am proud to tell people that I work for Alcoa; a company that takes its commitment to the community and its environmental stewardship very seriously. I look forward to many more years with this company, and your continued support is important in making that possible.
- TDS090119 -
Richmond/MyselfBPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Really, that's an overly kind way to frame it. More accurately the whole concept of sticking any group - public or private - with a tab to subsidize any business entity is unfair, socialistic and immoral. Alcoa et. al. can complain until the moon turns to cheese about their inability to turn a profit/continue to operate/employ however many thousands/etc., but that doesn't change the fact that I can't be expected to shoulder any portion of their power bill any more than I would be able to expect them to pay for mine. Any argument that “these businesses provide more for the surrounding communities than they take” is bollix. Half a billion dollars is a lot to take, especially in these downward-trending economic times. If they can’t operate their business on a model that doesn’t include perpetrating grand larceny on other energy customers, they shouldn’t be in business. The fact that BPA is even looking at this proposal with anything but distain and fits of laughter is flatly ridiculous. An increase in energy rates to anyone at this time will drive up unemployment and cause undue hardship for more than just Alcoa and Glencore. My job - as well as the jobs of my family members, friends and community - are just as important as any in Ferdale. If Alcoa/Glencore can’t pay their power bills, do the same thing to them you would do to anyone else: turn off the lights. Sincerely, Jim Richmond
- TDS090120 -
Saven/Northwest Requirements Utilities
- TDS090121 -
/Blachly Lane Electric Co-opOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090122 -
Fischer/My FamilyDear Mr. Wright, I agree with your proposal for a power contract to the DSI’s, especially to furnish our local Intalco Smelter with a seven year agreement. Yes, I know that this is a very controversial proposal to some customers. However, I think people forget that Intalco has been a good customer for decades. I don’t think that supplying a smaller amount of power than has been supplied to the smelter for years, at what I would consider to be the wholesale rate for the DSI’s that has been mutually agreed upon, could be considered a subsidy as many have argued. Let’s face it, the Northwest has grown and now requires more power for its longtime and newer customers. I don’t believe that warrants forcing big Industry that has counted on this power for years, off the grid simply to keep the rest of the ratepayers from accepting some of the burden. My power bill will keep going up in Washington, just as it has in the last 54 years as a resident in Bellingham. Intalco’s power bill will do the same. This is simply a matter of supply and demand. Thanks for doing the right thing and at least giving these industries a chance at survival in these tough economic times. The area will be much better off.
- TDS090123 -
Carter/Pacific Northwest Economic Stability
- TDS090124 -
Hines/myselfOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090125 -
Peavy/SelfI have worked at Intalco Alcoa for about 3 years now and really enjoy working here. During these tough times it is really upsetting not knowing what the future holds.I know with this tough economic time, jobs are hard to find and I hope that you will keep our plant running so that we have a secure future. Thank you for working so hard with us to come to an agreement and please continue to support us so that we can continue to have our family wage jobs and continue to help out our community and our families. Chaz Peavy
- TDS090126 -
Jorgensen/selfFirst, I want to thank BPA for continuing talks to supply power to the DSIs. It still amazes me that they are separated into a different group from the Weyerhouser, Kimberly Clarks, etc that receive power at the normal rate and the DSIs are supposed to pay more - that doesn't sound seem like a subsidy to me. My history tells me that the aluminum industry were the ones that intially helped to start BPA and supplied aluminum during war time. I am saddened of how many people forget that we are talking mainly about real people and real jobs with real families. So many of the negative comments are aimed for Alcoa as a company, not the indiviuals that work and live in that community. Wouldn't you fight for your job? I don't think anyone believes that one job is more important than the other. If the company that you work for ever runs into this situation you best hope that the employees at Intalco support you...they've lived through this more than once and survived!
- TDS090127 -
Loughnan/selfGood lord, give Alcoa the power, keep jobs in the U.S. It really is that simple.
- TDS090128 -
Tennent/selfI support the contract with Alcoa and the other DSI's. The negative comments on here are terrible and those of you who think your job or community is any more deserving than another should think again. And a half a billion dollars? Where did that amount come from? It is incorrect and misleading people. A subsidy? How about Alcoa just pay the same rate as the rest of its customers? Agrue that.
- TDS090129 -
I support this power contract with Alcoa and their employees who take the time to write from their heart. By the way opponents, the form letters (even used in parts) are lame, again.
- TDS090130 -
Bailey/eProject Services, Corp
- TDS090131 -
Ross/Myself and my own opinionsCanned opposition without individual thought or evidences a real lack understanding of the economic situation we all face. If some of the Blachly-Lane Coop members were facing the loss of a vital industry in their county and the crushing of their dreams for their families’ futures, they might not be so quick to press the Submit key on this patently false information. Previously this tactic was used by a large wood products company who had their employees send in canned submission, much like this one. That company has since abandoned this region and those employees. It is a shame that people will not do their own research and form their own opinions before trying to affect public policy, historically only harm is done when a mob mentality prevails. BPA should service the DSI’s in the Northwest because it is the right thing to do. These companies came here and enriched this region because BPA was created to support industry in this area. Asking Alcoa and other companies to abandon their considerable investments here makes no economic sense.
- TDS090136 -
bell/alcoa intalcoto whom it may concern id like to thank you for you continued support in working with us on the power dilema we face at intalco ive worked here for 3 years and im the soul income for my wife and two chlidren this is a good job and a inportant part of are comunity we have a saying around here that the men and women who work here have intalco dna thats because most of us are second and third generation employees any place where family members have worked for over fourty years is not only a asset to the comunity but a job worth fighting for thank you bryan bell
- TDS090137 -
Curtright/Alcoa Intalco WorksPlease save our jobs. This job has supported my family of five. The medical is also very important since I have a disabled 5 year old daughter.
- TDS090132 -
Jappert/selfThese are scary times for all of us. Job security, rising cost of living, our future seems to be more unstable than in the past. Intalco provides financial stability to 500+ families in western Washington; BPA has provided the Alcoa plants of Washington with power for over 50 years and Intalco with power for over 40 years. Alcoa and BPA has quite a history of cooperation and give and take and now we are asking BPA not for assistance but for an equitable and fair power plan for the future. Your positive decision on the current proposal by September of 2009 would provide stability for Intalco and would enable Intalco to continue to support the community, locally and state, and also allow Intalco to be an industry leader in environmental issues such as Greenhouse gas reduction. Thank-you for your efforts so far. Sincerely, Jody Jappert
- TDS090133 -
Macdonald/MyselfMr. Wright, Mr. Burns & Staff, I would like to thank all of you for your efforts in developing draft contracts with the DSIs that will give these companies an opportunity to continue to provide employment. Being a previous employee of Goldendale Aluminum, I have seen the catastrophic financial effects that a plant closure has on a community. The City of Goldendale and Klickitat County have still not recovered from the Goldendale Aluminum plant closure. On average, a dollar will be exchanged eight times before leaving a community. Nowhere is this fact more obvious that in Klickitat County. The trickledown effect of the plant closure has caused higher unemployment in all segments of work force. Based on my first hand observations, I can assure you, the studies you have read do not fully describe the devastating economic effects of a smelter closure on a community. During the current economic condition the Pacific Northwest needs to retain these smelter jobs. The average smelter wage is 15% - 20% above the Washington State average. I encourage you to continue you efforts in establishing contracts with the smelters. I realize that it is not BPA’s responsibility to keep the smelters operating, but they should be entitled to power the same as all other BPA customers. The aluminum industry has been a customer of BPA power since 1937 and should be allowed to continue to be a customer into the future. Please continue your work and establish contracts with the DSIs. Thank you, Rob Macdonald, PE
- TDS090134 -
Sires/Alcoa Intalco WorksTo whom it may concern, I am writing this comment in support of the ongoing power supply to Alcoa Intalco Works. This fine organization has been a staple in the northwest, providing not only family based wages to the citizens of Washington State but also supporting local organizations in charity donations, a helping hand or simply a word of encouragment to the many people Intalco calls neighbors. I have been a part of Intalco since I can remember, in fact the day I was born I was part of the Intalco family. You see my father was an electrician for intalco for over 30 years. He started here before I was born. His job and the security it brang provided me with not only a car when I turned 16, new shoes for school but also a pride of being a part of company that was known for its workforce and its dedication to the community. I am currently an employee at Intalco as is my brother. Intalco is a family to me. It always has been and always will. Each year me and my family look forward to the annual picnic. For the last two years I will be able to brin my family and sign in under my own name. I signed in under my fathers name for countless year before I was employed by Intalco. I hope you take the time to read this,
- TDS090135 -
WilliamsonTo Whom It May Concern: As a 20+ year employee at Intalco, I urge the BPA to provide power to Intalco at a DSI rate. I work at a company that has shown through the years that is is an economically viable, environmentally aware, community minded and safe place to work. The economic impact of plant closure would not be something I would like to experience as a resident of Whatcom County. I believe it would be a downturn that would take many years for the local economy to overturn, and would be devastating to the employees affected by it. Intalco is a needed employer in the area, especially in the troubled economy we are presently experiencing. Personally, the loss of employment would be difficult to overcome and the loss of income would be difficlut to replace. Please make a decision to continue Intalco's long history as a BPA customer and allow this plant to continue to be positive contributor to this area. Larry Williamson
- TDS090138 -
Farrar/MyselfThank you for working with Alcoa towards a power deal, and for taking the time to consider the comments submitted from interested people like me. While you will, no doubt, receive many “canned” objections to continuing to serve Alcoa the power it needs to remain viable; you will also receive many requests, like mine, from people who have a personal stake in the future of this region. We are living in very tough economic times and adding more families to the unemployment rolls helps no one and hurts us all. Many local businesses depend on the Alcoa employees as an important part of their customer base; many non-profits in this community depend on the support they get from Alcoa and its employees; many manufacturers (employers) up and down the west coast depend on the raw materials we provide Alcoa has been a long time customer of BPA and this relationship has benefited this region. These uncertain economic time we are going through are not the time to stop the service of Federal power to a long time customer and valuable employer. I have been employed by Alcoa-Intalco for over 40 years. My employment has made it possible for me to remain in Whatcom County where I grew up, and to raise my family here. Now I have grandchildren here and their future concerns me as well. I see other young people starting out at Intalco, getting ready to start families and looking forward to a bright future, and I hope that the same opportunities that I enjoyed will be available to them and their families. Please do what you can to make sure that a deal is in place in time to allow continuous operation of this plant.
- TDS090139 -
Hemnes/SelfTo Whom it may concern, Thank you for working hard to secure a fair power contract for Alcoa Intalco Works for at least 7 years. A fair power contract enables our plant to compete in a Global Market and protect 500 family wage jobs in our Community in these uncertain Economic times. Thanks again for your continued efforts to bring resolution to this issue.
- TDS090140 -
Joseph/selfI am a hard working employee of Alcoa Intalco Works. Thank you for negotiating the power contract with us. This job has allowed me to buy a new car. Aquire land to build my home on and provide me with the healthcare benefits to take care of myself. I am in support of Intalco once again thank you. Aaron Joseph
- TDS090141 -
Koch/selfOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Karen Koch member Blachly-Lane Co-op
- TDS090142 -
Pixler/AlcoaBPA, Thank you for keeping negotiations going forward with Intalco regarding our future power supply. There are a lot of people in this plant that are very motivated to keep this plant open. I have just moved to the state of Washington 2 years ago from Ohio. This is a beautiful state, and I want to stay. Without this job I may have to move again, but when you present a contact that works for Intalco and BPA I will be able to purchase my first home, get married, and have children. This plant has opened the door to a long term career and opened the door to relationships that are very valuable; please continue to work hard with completing a contract. Key facts to remember: 1.) Intalco has been a long term customer of BPA and a major supporter to the region and its growth. Our objectives as people of the community are the same as your goals to keep jobs at this plant and in the region. 2.) Intalco needs this contract completed by September or our future could change very quickly in a bad way. Don’t wait, now is the time to act. 3.) Now is not the time to stop power service of federal power to historical customer, this will only contributed to the current economic conditions. Completing a contract before September is the right thing to do. Sincerely, Joshua M. Pixler
- TDS090143 -
/SelfDear BPA, I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate BPA’s proposed terms of service for DSI’s and want to reiterate how important it is that the contract gets completed by September. I was born and raised in this community and hope to finishing raising my children here and with a mid to long term power deal I will be able to do that. These are uncertain times so we need this issue to be resolved quickly in order for this facility to survive. Intalco needs to maintain a two line operation, at the court order IP rate for this facility, to be profitable and productive. This is a great facility that gives so much to our community we hope it will be able to get a long term contract to provide more security for employees and the local community. With the economy the way it is now is not the time to stop service of Federal power to historical customers. Thanks for your time, Wendy Reid
- TDS090144 -
Boorman/City of Bonners FerryDuring these tough economic times, particularly in a timber based community, it is very difficult to see selected industries being subsidized by our struggling consumers. The case of below cost power rates for jobs could be made for any number of local businesses in Bonners Ferry, North Idaho, and the Northwest. We are not opposed to selling power to the historical DSIs at an industrial firm power rate, until it increases the rates and reduces the viability of other northwest industries. sincerly Stephen Boorman City of Bonners Ferry
- TDS090145 -
SMITH/INTACOI have worked at Intalco for 21 years. I would so much like you to provide power to Inalco.Not just for me but for the 500 other employs.thank you.
- TDS090146 -
Daulph/SelfThank you BPA, for continually trying to reach a long term contract to service the DSI’s. Intalco Alcoa Works should be treated like other industries in the Northwest and be given fair power prices. An independent economic study has shown that every Alcoa Intalco Works job generates another 2.9 jobs in the community. Given the current economic downturn, it is more important than ever to ensure that these jobs are protected. I urge you to continue your 70 year history of supplying power to Aluminum smelters in the NW and work towards long term contracts benefiting all parties. Aluminum production will continue throughout the world with or without companies in America. Our country needs a good economic base of manufacturing products to survive. Alcoa supports giving back to the communities in which we live in. I have had the pleasure of not only donating my time, but working alongside with many who donate not only time, but money and resources through non- profits to enhance our region. Alcoa is environmentally sound and a steward that many should take the time and learn from. Jobs need to remain in the NW. Alcoa has become an integrated member of the economy providing good middle class wage employment. It is vital to our future that a long term solution is achieved. Job stability in the NW is a key to our success. Let’s keep local jobs protected. Regards, Tia Daulph
- TDS090147 -
Knauft/MyselfTo Whom It May Concern: Thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. My father has worked at Alcoa Intalco for over 25 years, so a long-term power contract is vital for my future endeavors and my family, and numerous families throughout the area. Without affordable power, it would be difficult to plan for my family’s future. One cannot ignore the integrated economic value of protecting this NW business. The vast majorities of Intalco’s customers are located on the West Coast of North America and currently include manufacturers in Washington and Oregon. I hope you can understand what it means to me, my family, and numerous people that depend on Alcoa Intalco Works for jobs and community structure. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract. The strength of my family, my community and this region depends upon it. Sincerely, Nikole Knauft
- TDS090148 -
Oplinger/Bellingham Whatcom Chamber of Commerce and IndustryOn behalf of the business community across Whatcom County, and our tens of thousands of employees, we agree with the Term Sheet that has been developed, and ask BPA to move forward to finalize negotiations with Intalco as quickly as possible.
- TDS090149 -
Mgr/Idaho County Light and Power CooperativeTo the Administrator: On behalf of the 3,600 Members and the 7 member Board of Directors of Idaho County Light & Power Cooperative (ICLP), we are opposed to any sale by the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA) to the Direct Service Industry (DSI) customers that would result in an increase to the cooperative's cost of power and/or transmission services and therefore to our members. This is not only our request, it is BPA's legal responsibility to the public power customers of the region. We strongly urge you to uphold that responsibility and maintain that commitment. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Jake Eimers, Mgr. Idaho County Light & Power Cooperative Assoc., Inc.
- TDS090150 -
Vallejo/Self - and FamilyOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Please consider revising the proposal to ensure that public utilities and their customers are not adversely affected on the backs of private corporations. Thank you. Jared Vallejo
- TDS090151 -
Kemp/selfI see that you are in the process of creating more sweetheart deals with the aluminum smelters, including having us assume the risk if they decide to walk away from the deals. Please do not ask us to further subsidize the aluminum smelters. Their past actions have shown that they are not overly concerned about their employee's jobs and will "play the market" with publicly subsidized power. Shifting jobs from ratepayer businesses around the region to these two aluminum smelters via subsidized energy is not good policy. Thank you; Michael Kemp
- TDS090152 -
Knauft/MyselfTo Whom It May Concern: Thank you for working with Alcoa to develop a power contract that provides Intalco with the opportunity to continue to operate for at least the next seven years. My husband has worked at Alcoa Intalco for over 25 years, so a long-term power contract is vital for my family, and numerous families throughout the area. Without affordable power, it would be difficult to plan for our family's future. One cannot ignore the integrated economic value of protecting this NW business. The vast majorities of Intalco's customers are located on the West Coast of North America and currently include manufacturers in Washington and Oregon. I hope you can understand what it means to me, my family, and numerous people that depend on Alcoa Intalco Works for jobs and community structure. Thank you again for your efforts to bring this issue to a successful resolution through the provision of a minimum seven-year contract. The strength of my family, my community and this region depends upon it. Sincerely, Charlene L. Knauft
- TDS090153 -
ShefflerOur local businesses and members are already feeling the effects of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our local dollars to benefit private companies at our expense. Unjustified increases in electric rates for public power will lead to further job loss and financial strain for our region. Our community and the jobs in it are equally as important as those whom BPA is targeting. Thank you for reading this. Crystal Sheffler
- TDS090154 -
/Aaron and Benjamin JosephI'm a Ferndale school employee. If this Intalco leaves the area it will hurt the students that go to school in Ferndale. And I have two son's that work there.
- TDS090155 -
House/AlcoaI am writing on behalf of Alcoa Intalco Works in efforts to protect my future employment. Alcoa has provided me with a steady income and benifit package in which I (my family) have become greatly accustomed to. My job at Alcoa has afforded me to continue paying a mortgage, college tuition for my stepdaughter at WWU and to support my local community in which I live. I strongly urge you to please consider continuing to deliver power to Alcoa to preserve the jobs it provides. Thank you for your anticipated consideration.
- TDS090156 -
Gebhart/FamilyBPA, I know it seems a bit redundant to continually write and ask you to save jobs at the Alcoa Ferndale smelter, but I find it very important to do so. I appreciate all the work and effort that has gone into working towards an agreement that will mutually benefit both Alcoa and BPA. I have read all the comments and I appreciate the opposition’s point of views. The only concern here is that there are many families that are at risk of losing their only means of livelihood. I am sure that the utilities do not want to raise rates for their consumers. I am sure that most families can adjust by not buying one latte a week or whatever to make up the dollar increase, if any is to occur. I know that I will cut back in that area to make the difference up. The community can absorb and keep going with a small increase, but a community cannot survive a major shut down. Thank you for everything.
- TDS090157 -
Cameron/Lane Electric CoopAs a retiree on social security, I am outrsged that BPA would even consider a DSL contract of any kind, you raised the rates to my Co-op and then sudsidize these companies? Someone in BPA is selling out to private business. I will set up a howl to congress and to the media until we see a decrease in rates for us. And you can do it. If you can sell that cheap to aluminun companies, then you can sell cheaper to us. What the Towbopat companies waste in water spill alone on every trip up and down the Columbia and Snake would be a nice cut in power rates. Get real, I will not get a COLA increase for 2 years according to the government, so cut our rates and sell at full retail to the DSLs
- TDS090158 -
HarbisonI'm writing to let you know that BPA's proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa & Glencore at the expense of public power consomers is poor public policy, and worse yet, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies backing out of their power purchase leaving public power consumers responsible for these expenses. BPA should not enter into any agreement that uses our local dollars to benefit private companies at our expense. Unjustified increases in electrical rates for public power will lead to further job loss and financial strain elsewhere. Our community and jobs are equally as important as those whom BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Craig Harbison
- TDS090159 -
Arnason/SelfThank you B.P.A. for working with Alcoa on a power contract. A 7 year contract will be a huge economic benefit to all of Whatcom county. Keep Intalco's power supply coming so the next generation will have good job in the furture. Thank you Tod Arnason
- TDS090160 -
Dubigk/Northwest Workforce CouncilI write to you to express the support of the Northwest Workforce Council, a local, business-led, workforce investment board, for the efforts BPA has made to date in support of the 500+ at risk jobs at Alcoa Intalco Works in Ferndale, WA. An equitable power contract appears to be within reach of the negotiating parties, and with it, the retention of these advanced manufacturing jobs in our community. The partner organizations of our workforce system have worked closely with Alcoa Intalco Works. We recognize the contribution the plant's payroll makes to our regional economy and the import of maintaining a local manufacturing base. To operate profitably Alcoa must attain an equitable cost power contract from BPA. We ask that you proceed with the recently drafted term sheet to provide Alcoa the IP power rate as authorized by the 9th Circuit Court decision. The impact of losing over 500 family wage jobs in our region is something from which our regional economy would not soon recover. We urge you to provide Alcoa Intalco Works the power contract terms needed to keep our families working and our region's economic vitality strong. Sincerely, Gay Dubigk Executive Director Northwest Workforce Council PO Box 2009 Bellingham, WA 98227
- TDS090161 -
Luzzo/selfI understand that Franklin County PUD's General Manager Ed Brost has a problem with Alaco Inc.'s hydroelectric power related tax break. In October of 2002, I submitted USE OF THE TRADE ACT PROGRAM HOW KAISER ALUNIMUM WORKERS STEELWORKERS HAVE BEEN HELPED IN SPOKANE COUNTY; to Webster University. This was a Master Degree Thesis that supported steelworkers in a labor dispute with their corporate owner, Maxum Corporation. Henry Kaisers Company in later years was in fact owned by this Corporation. The labor dispute is not being discussed here. What I am stating that Henry Kaiser bought the war surplus steel manufacturing plant owned by Alcoa and located in Tacoma. He moved this steel manufacturing line to Spokane. This was incorporated in a common steel manufacturing conglomerate collocated between Mead and Trentwood Washington. He was also able to broker a deal using hydroelectric power from Grand Coulee Dam for his 2 plants. This helped him build a local aluminum manufacturing industry in the Spokane area. Offering tax breaks and power reducing cost saving measures is in fact; sound economic policy. Henry's Kaisers' company Kaiser Aluminum and Chemical Corporation, created such products as seamless aluminum cans, Kolacolor Film, the steel for the US Air Force Academy's Chapel at Colorado Springs and steel ingots for other uses. He employed steelworkers in 2 union locals. He was part of a deal between his corporation, the Bonneville Power Administration and Boeing Aircraft. I don’t know where Mr. Brost is coming from, but the Tri City area is in fact, still quite short in terms of manufacturing potential in terms of growth. Yet he wants to complain about corporate breaks provided for what making it easier to manufacture something? If the Franklin County PUD's General Manager has a problem with this, let him commission a study on offering better manufacturing incentives within his county. I also suggest that he read a little about Adam Smith's economic theory that rational self interest and the competition of a free market can lead to economic well being and prosperity. Michael Luzzo Kennewick Washington
- TDS090162 -
HazenI disagree with a decision to subsidize aluminum smelter companies at public power’s expense. Our community and the jobs in it are equally as important as those whom BPA is targeting. Our local businesses and members are already feeling the effects of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our local dollars to benefit private companies at our expense. Unjustified increases in electric rates for public power will lead to further job loss and financial strain for our region.
- TDS090163 -
/rate payersOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090164 -
Stuth/Myself and familyI would like to thank the BPA for working so hard and so quickly to draft this current term sheet. I would also like to encourage you to proceed with this contract offering to Alcoa. I am a 10 year employee at the Intalco plant, and can't imagine the impact losing this facility would mean for this community and my family. Intalco has been a fixture here for over forty years. Paying good wages, supporting local businesses, and giving generously to local charities. Without a stable, long term power contract at a fair rate this plant is in serious jeopardy of leaving this community. So please, I urge you to finalize this contract with Alcoa as quickly as possible. Thank you. Andy Stuth and family
- TDS090165 -
Bernard/myselfAs a second generation Intalco worker, I have lived here all my life as well as my entire family. This facility has always supported a lot of families in the Great Pacific Northwest. Years ago, when the BPA had the extra power, when they needed to sell the extra power, they fluctuated the cost by the LME price. Higher LME, higher power cost. Lower LME, lower power. I thank the BPA for agreeing at the proposed rate to keep this great workforce alive and well. Jason Bernard
- TDS090166 -
Furnas/Alcoa Intalco WorksI applaude BPA in working with Alcoa to find a solution that 1) makes economic sense for the region and 2) allows over 500 people to keep their jobs and support their families. I have lived in Whatcom County my whole life and started working at Intalco when I was 20 years old. While I am very appreciative of the job that Alcoa has provided me, there have been other benefits that my job has provided over the years besides a salary. Alcoa has paid for my college tuition, for which I am eternally grateful. Alcoa has also supported many volunteer opportunities and charitable causes that I feel strongly about. When the smelter curtailed in 2001, we were able to deploy over 80 employees into the local community to do volunteer work. You can imagine how well this was received in the non-profit community, especially after another large employer in the region had recently shut down due to high power costs. Stability and a long term business plan allows large companies like Alcoa to provide many benefits for their employees and the community they live in. Alcoa has shown it's commitment to the Intalco smelter many times over the last 9 years and continues to do so now, even in the economic downturn. Why? We have a good workforce, a safe plant and we run an efficient business. Please work with us to continue to provide all three for the area. Thank you.
- TDS090167 -
RichmondOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. I don't understand how a public utility that is funded by our tax dollars could give preference to a small special interest than the rest of the jobs and livelihoods of the rest of its patrons. Sincerely, Johnathan Richmond
- TDS090168 -
Brost/Franklin PUDFranklin PUD objects to and urges BPA not to enter into any contract with Alcoa pursuant to the proposed term sheet or CFAC under similar terms. BPA has no obligation to serve these companies and the cost and risks being assumed by BPA, all of which fall onto to BPA public customers and their ratepayers, are unacceptable. Franklin PUD strongly believes that the proposed contracts clearly do not serve a legitimate business interest of BPA. The economic consequences, which will likely include loss of many other regional long-term jobs while perhaps keeping a struggling industry temporarily afloat are too great for BPA to ask their primary customers to bear. Saving 600 jobs at such a high cost at the expense of 1300 others is not supoortable. Franklin PUD supports the comments of the Public Power Council on this matter. Again, Franklin PUD strongly urges BPA to reconsider the proposed actions. Thank you.
- TDS090169 -
Bishop/My FamilyAlcoa is a long term supplier os high paying manufacturing jobs in this country and I encourage the B.P.A. to estend Their electricity contract for the next 7 years. The above action is in the best interest of President Obama's plan to keep existing jobs from moving overseas and to help end this current recession. Your consideration of the above coments is appreciated. Harvey W. Bishop Private Citizen
- TDS090170 -
ClarksonAs a retiree,on absolute fixed income, I strongly object to the proposal of subsidizing DSIs and passing the loss onto "no clout" rate payers. Is their no compassion for the elderly? Do we have to die penniless before you're happy?
- TDS090171 -
Bishop/My FamilyAlcoa is a long term supplier os high paying manufacturing jobs in this country and I encourage the B.P.A. to extend Their electricity contract for the next 7 years. The above action is in the best interest of President Obama's plan to keep existing jobs from moving overseas and to help end this current recession. Your consideration of the above comments is appreciated. Harvey W. Bishop Private Citizen
- TDS090172 -
Orcutt/selfThe proposed rate for the aluminum producers amounts to a subsidy to them, at the expense of all other ratepayers. Why purchase relatively expensive wind generation at the same time artificially and unnecessarily driving up demand by aluminum producers? Jobs will be lost by those employers forced to pay artificially high power rates. The proposed rate case would not save jobs on a net basis; it would simply use public/ratepayer money to favor one industry over, and at the cost of, the rest of the employers in the Pacific Northwest. The proposed subsidy for aluminum companies is bad economics and bad public policy.
- TDS090173 -
McGuire/Self
Dear Steve Wright and BPA Staff: Please add my name in support of the July 17 Term Sheet for Block Power Sale to Alcoa. I am a thirty-four year employee at Alcoa Intalco supporting a wife and two teenage children. We are a single income family and a family wage job is what is necessary to meet our needs. Alcoa Intalco has provided such jobs for over 40 years and has been one of the key employers in our community. In addition, our plant has made great strides in reducing greenhouse gas in our operations and continues to look for ways to be responsible to our community needs. The proposed Term Sheet gives us the ability to survive the current economic downturn and move forward to better days ahead. My thanks go to Steve Wright and the BPA Staff for their efforts to fashion a power solution which can work for our smelter while being fair to the needs of the region. BPA has been charged to responsibly administer the power resources of this region and I do appreciate the effort to see that the DSI's are not left out of that commitment. Hopefully, the details of this proposal can be worked out soon. Sincerely, Dale McGuire
- TDS090174 -
Burns/IntalcoI am writing in support of the proposed terms of service for DSIs. In a time when our president and congress are wrestling with ways to create new family wage jobs here in the U.S.A. doesn't it make sense to save 550 family wage jobs here in Ferndale, Washington by insuring Intalco aluminum refinery has a secure source of electric power to operate competetively in the world marketplace? Our jobs are important to all of us here at Intalco as well as our families. I personally am alive simply because of the excellent medical benefits available here. My family wage job has allowed me to help my disabled sister and her family as well as my mentally ill nephew. It has provided discretionary income that has empowered me to support Big Brothers/Big Sisters of Whatcom County as well as other programs/ ministries that serve young people in our community and all around the world. America needs heavy industry like Intalco in order to provide not only family wage jobs, but to help secure our nation from foreign aggressors be they financial or military in nature. I respectfully submit for your consideration that providing 320 Megawatts of power to Intalco helps keep family wage jobs in Washington State and the U.S.A. at large, helps maintain the heavy industry infrastructure necessary for our nation's future economic success, and helps support our national security from enemies, financial, terrorist and military in nature. I urge you to ratify the Proposed Terms of Service for DSIs. Sincerely, Jerry Burns, CDP
- TDS090175 -
Morgan/selfThank you for your efforts in working to complete the power contract between Alcoa and BPA. The benefits to the northwest for completing this agreement will go on for a long time. Jobs and a steady tax base for communities help to maintain everyone's standard of living in good times and bad. With a positive decision on the power rate, the good times will continue to out wiegh and last longer than the bad times.
- TDS090176 -
JohnstonOur local businesses and members are already feeling the effects of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our local dollars to benefit private companies at our expense. Unjustified increases in electric rates for public power will lead to further job loss and financial strain for our region. Our community and the jobs in it are equally as important as those whom BPA is targeting. Sincerely,Ruth Johnston
- TDS090177 -
Horst/SelfThanks to BPA for continuing to work on a contract to power the Intalco facility for seven more years. I’ve had the pleasure of visiting or working at Alcoa facilities world-wide, and I’ve seen consistent commitment to communities, the environment, and our employees. In the midst of corporate failures and bailouts that have occurred over the past several years, Alcoa has not asked for anything more than fair treatment mirroring that of every other BPA customer. We believe that lightweight, strong, and endlessly recyclable aluminum is part of the solution to climate change. Peter Senge acknowledges Alcoa’s environmental leadership in his 2008 tome on corporate responsibility, The Necessary Revolution. In addressing our unrelenting commitment to waste reduction and employee safety, Senge elaborates: “These targets…were right because they tapped to the fullest people’s capacities to learn, and eventually led to otherwise unachievable accomplishments. The same holds for the future.” We strive to provide value in every aspect of our business, far beyond simply asking our investors to continue to believe in us. The Intalco facility alone contributes $190 million dollars our nation’s GDP and $60 million directly to the economy of Whatcom County and surrounding areas. Given a future, we will continue to press for unachievable accomplishments, and we will continue to deliver. A few months ago when the picture was somewhat dimmer, I spent significant time listening to co-workers; really hearing the story that each had to tell. They’re all different, they all contain their hardships and their joys, but we’re all committed individually and collectively to the health of the region. I’ve been in Whatcom County for only 18 months, but I feel like I’ve finally found a home. I’m working on a Masters degree and I sit on a non-profit board in Bellingham. I’m making my own small impact, and I’m so proud of each of the ~1,500 people who are directly or indirectly employed by the Intalco facility for the mark they’re leaving on Whatcom County. Thank you for working to ensure that we’ll be here to make a difference for years to come.
- TDS090178 -
Soderlund/selfThis is to encourage you to finalize the current proposed electrical service contract offer to Alcoa Intalco, Ferndale, Washington. This company division is a very large employer of local people in this area, and has been for years. It will be devestating to lose this payroll and, additional personnel of supporting vendors and service contractors to this company! Help keep this company alive and Competitive in the world market.
- TDS090179 -
Johansen/SelfIntalco is an establishment that is vital to families in this area. During a time when jobs are in short supply and high demand it seems like there is really only one answer to this issue. Help us keep good, family wage jobs local.
- TDS090180 -
MartinOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090181 -
PfanderI am writing to let you know that BPA's proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa and Glencore at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase leaving pulic power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our local dollars to benefit private companies at our expense. Unjustified increases in electric rates for public power will lead to further job loss and financial strain for our communities. Our community and the jobs in it are equally as improtant as those whom BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Ellen i pfander
- TDS090182 -
WalkerOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting.
- TDS090183 -
Henley/SelfI want to thank you for working so diligently with Alcoa on coming up with an agreement that can keep us running especially suring these tough economic times. Alcoa provides a nice family wage job with benefits to over 500 employees. Alcoa and its employees are very involved in our community and our environment. We take great pride in both. Alcoa has been a good customer of BPA for 70+ years now and it would be devastating to not only Alcoa but to our community if this facility were to close. All we've been asking for was to treat us the same as your other customers and this is definately a step in the right direction. Again thanks for working with us and I sincerely hope we'll continue working together for many more years.
- TDS090184 -
family/SelfBPA, I know it seems a bit redundant to continually write and ask you to save jobs at the Alcoa Ferndale smelter, but I find it very important to do so. I appreciate all the work and effort that has gone into working towards an agreement that will mutually benefit both Alcoa and BPA. I have read all the comments and I appreciate the opposition's point of views. The only concern here is that there are many families that are at risk of losing their only means of livelihood. I am sure that the utilities do not want to raise rates for their consumers. I am sure that most families can adjust by not buying one latte a week or whatever to make up the dollar increase, if any is to occur. I know that I will cut back in that area to make the difference up. The community can absorb and keep going with a small increase, but a community cannot survive a major shut down. Thank you for everything.
- TDS090185 -
Porter/Benton REAAllen Burns, Acting Deputy Administrator August 2, 2009 Bonneville Power Administration P.O. Box 3621 Portland, Oregon 97208 Submitted Via BPA Public Comment Website Benton REA DSI Comments Dear Mr. Burns, Benton Rural Electric Association (Benton REA) submits the following comments for your consideration. The July 17, 2009, Draft Term Sheet suggests changes to the proposed Alcoa sale that do not improve the draft contract, and in fact compounds the financial risks for preference customers. We provide the following examples: • The liquidated damages provisions of the draft contract, previously inadequate, are now absent from the term sheet. • There is no mention of $20 million in credit assurance originally in the draft contract. • The less than clear commitment in the draft contract to require a $200 million capital investment over ten years by Alcoa is absent. • There is new, confusing, and open-ended language on the term sheet that affords Alcoa an immediate exit right in the event that costs associated with renewable energy standard obligations, “carbon taxes or charges, greenhouse gas mitigation costs, or other similar environmental or regulatory charges are not recovered by BPA through rates but are to be paid by Alcoa under the terms on the contract.” (point 5) Does this mean that if BPA enters such a contract, and Alcoa terminates, then those costs must be paid by BPA’s remaining customers? Benton REA struggles to understand why it is that BPA continues to subsidize the DSI’s at the expense of public power customers. We and other public power entities have continued to submit comments to BPA on this issue which seem to make absolutely no difference to the Agency. BPA continues to pour money into the DSI’s at the expense of all other northwest rate payers. If the Agency truly believes that survival of this industry has national security implications, necessary subsidy funding should come from the Federal government, not from northwest rate payers. Sincerely, John Porter Benton REA Mgr of Finance
- TDS090186 -
Williams/United Electric Coop, Inc.Bonneville should not subsidize one particular industry or group of workers over others. Jobs are being lost throughout the northwest. Many businesses have been forced into closing their doors. To subsidize the DSI's is wrong and I implore you to look at the equity in doing so.
- TDS090187 -
Rousseau/SelfI am a retired person with a family member working at the Alcoa plant in Ferndale WA. This plant is operating under threat of closure because of power rates. Alcoa at Ferndale provides 500 family wage jobs. I have seen what Alcoa provides to the community and state in employment, taxes and charitable donations. Alcoa employees are very community minded and donate many hundreds of community service hours. Much of the manufacturing in the United Sates has moved off shore. With this move we have seen the loss of family wage jobs. This is an issue for national security. I feel it is imperative we keep Alcoa in Ferndale. 25% of their production stays in the Pacific NW. Aluminum is a product that will have increasing importance in coming years for manufacturing fuel efficient vehicles. This plant is operated with employee safety foremost and under very strict environment guide lines, Aluminum plants in China and some other parts of the world do not have these operating standards. Please do what you can to keep Alcoa a viable business in Washington. Whatcom County, the State of Washington and the United Sates need Alcoa. Thank you for your support Phil Rousseau
- TDS090188 -
Elias/McMinnville Water and LightI disagree with your proposal. You have no obligation to serve them, you have obligation to provide a special rate, it does not make good business sense. MY first reaction when I heard the announcement: they must truely have strong political influence to gain special benefit for so few at the expense of so many.
- TDS090189 -
Morgan/selfThank you for your efforts in working to complete the power contract between Alcoa and BPA. The benefits to the northwest for completing this agreement will go on for a time. Jobs and a steady tax base help to maintain everyone's standard of living in good times and bad. With a positive decision on the power rate, the good times will continue to out weigh the bad times.
- TDS090190 -
Wilson/selfThe employees at Intalco, their family and friends as well as the community deserve to keep the facility in Whatcom County. I am pleased that we are close to a contract. As an employee and active member in the community, I know the impact that losing these jobs would have to Whatcom County. Each one of us needs to work diligently to keep jobs in the U.S. and to remember that we all have families that depend on us. This Term Sheet brings us one step closer. Thank you
- TDS090191 -
Menchaca/familyThank you for working with us here at Intalco Alcoa Works in Ferndale WA. Being the only bread winner in the family home,it will be great to put bread on the table for the next years to come. For my wife to rase our girls is a blessing & many familys are blessed if we can continue to work and keep this community going. Thanks again ...G.M.
- TDS090192 -
KroodsmaDear Sirs: Is it not enough that during these economic times that the private citizens are paying for every thing you can think of? What will the cost be if this venture fails? The cost will be once again to the private citizens who had no say so, no vote and to whom no one listens to anymore. We just keep paying the price. This is absurd. Sheri Kroodsma
- TDS090193 -
Mundorf/WPAG
- TDS090194 -
Scott/Franklin County General PublicOur community’s businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I’m writing to let you know that BPA’s proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc. and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our community’s dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Sincerely, Kathleen Scott
- TDS090195 -
Eckert/President, Bellingham Technical CollegeThank you for continuing to resolve the issue of providing Alcoa Intalco Works with a reasonable power rate that allows them to stay in business. As I'm sure you are aware, Intalco employs more than 500 people, and it is essential we keep these folks employed and continuing to inject some 60 million dollars annually into our local economoy. I urge you to move forward with the current rate proposal as presented on the Term Sheet and to continue working for reasonable power rates beyond 2016.
- TDS090196 -
Durkin/SelfDear BPA; Thank you for your continued work with Alcoa to allow Intalco an opportunity to stay operational for at least the next seven years. Intalco employees are wonderful people and deserving of a long awaited contract with BPA. As it states in BPA’s mission – your roll is to serve power and deliver power to NW customers. Alcoa is a 70 year customer and deserves the fair treatment/rates that all other customers from BPA benefit from. Intalco employees have relentlessly reduced costs of the operations to continue to fight and see another day. Now is the time to seal the deal with Alcoa, to benefit the employees, the community they support and the local businesses and customers that the operations of the plant help support. Thank you for your continued support in seeking resolution for a seven year contract. We all are awaiting final resolution and signatures. Sincerely, Jennifer Durkin
- TDS090197 -
Turnbow/Alcoa RetireeDear Administrator Wright: As a past Plant Manager at Alcoa's Intalco Works, I want to personally thank you for your work with Alcoa/Intalco to resolve the issue power to this industrial entity. The Intalco workers are strong, loyal Americans that operate a highly productive, clean and efficient aluminum smelter. Cooperation between Management and the IAM should be considered as a model for American industry. Thanks again for your hard work and willingness to find a mutually acceptable power arrangement for at least the next seven years. Gerald A. Turnbow
- TDS090198 -
Carpenter/Raft River Rural ElectricRaft River Electric opposes any BPA contract with the aluminum companies that uses the PF customer’s rates to fund the agreement. All of our industries in the Northwest are struggling and a subsidy in the magnitude that is being considered sacrifices jobs in some areas for the benefit of employment in others. BPA should use prudent business practices and charge the aluminum companies a rate for energy that is reflective of the cost to serve the load.
- TDS090199 -
Workentin/selfTo BPA...I am commenting on behalf of Alcoa securing a long term power contract at favorable rates.As we have seen so many jobs go out of our country, we are becoming a non exporter of goods. You have a chance to save jobs that produce a product that will not need to be imported and can be exported also.Since these jobs are in the pacific north west it is of even greater importance to us that live here. If there is an opportunity to keep jobs here or create new jobs we must take advantage of it. We need to secure a future for our state and region. Please supply the necessary power and contract to Alcoa.It is especially important during this nations economic crisis. THANK YOU
- TDS090200 -
/Whatcom CountyAs an Ex-Alcoan who was "laid-off", I was inside and am extremely aware of the situation. Alcoa, as a multinational corporation, should not be subsidized by anyone. They are a great deal responsible for flooding the market with their product and are now directly responsible for their current financial situation. When the prices for aluminum were high, I remember a lot of mandatory overtime. Next thing we hear is how all the world warehouses are over filled with raw aluminum and now smelters are having to lay off employees that worked hard for them and curtailment. You will receive almost no support for smelters by anyone understanding that their taxes are subsidizing them. All the thank you letters are form letters from current employees and supervisors, most being told to do so, and are recognized favorably for doing so. Do NOT subsidize Aluminum smelters like Alcoa Intalco Works. They have billions of dollars with which to pay their own way....just like us smaller people have to do!
- TDS090201 -
Brawley/PNGC Power
- TDS090202 -
Hagen/Clearwater Power Company
- TDS090203 -
Rousseau/Retired Mason County PUD CustomerI am a Mason County PUD customer and I fully support the BPA furnishing power at a rate to keep the Ferndale Alcoa Plant working.
- TDS090204 -
Smith/Grays Harbor PUD
- TDS090205 -
Farmer/SelfBy giving Alcoa Intalco Works a workable power contract, BPA can do a great service to the employees and communities affected. The 500+ direct jobs as well those created indirectly are greatly needed by community and the country as a whole. The employees at Intalco have weathered tough times to gain this opportunity. Please do the right thing for them and their communities.
- TDS090206 -
Ericson/Self and FamilyI would like to thank BPA for continuing to negoteate a power contract with Alcoa. Alcoa and BPA have worked together for deccades to produce aluinum and in the process help support the northwests economy. This is a family wage job, and with so many struggling at this time is is vital to our compay, and our familys, that we recieve a decision soon. Hundreds of familys will be affected by this decisison. For me alcoa has allowed me as a single mother to provide for my children, buy a home and car, and fund my tuition so that I could return to college. Alcoa has provided well for my self and my family.As it has for generations. I am asking that you help keep this legacy going by providing Alcoa with a speedy decision in favor of the power contract that is needed & at a fair rate.
- TDS090207 -
Teffeteller/SelfDear Mr. Wright, I am writing today in support of the proposed term sheet between the BPA and Alcoa's Intalco Works. I strongly urge making every effort to complete this contract by September. I appreciate the effort the BPA has put into this process not only in terms of being willing to listen to new proposals, but also in the openess and integrity your agency has displayed in all our dealings. I am hopeful that our collective efforts will result in an equitable power contract that will let Intalco operate for the foreseeable future, preserving the livelihoods of 500 employees with the resulting impact to the surrounding community. I am a 25 year Alcoan who has been an employee of Intalco the past 2 years. I believe the spirit of Intalco is one of customer service, innovation, environmental stewardship, and commitment to both the employee and the community. This contract will allow that spirit to continue. I realize there are many individuals and groups opposed to providing power to the Direct Service Industries (DSIs). I would remind them of several points - (1) Alcoa's NW aluminum plants are a 50 year customer of BPA (2) we are asking for a cost based rate (IP) upheld in a recent Federal Court decision - no corporate subsidy (3) Alcoa has been and continues to be a positive contributor in the communities it chooses to operate. In reading through some of the comments posted to your website opposed to any contract with the aluminum industry, I could not help but notice that many were from Oregon. My family just returned from a vacation to the Oregon coast. Those beaches and the surrounding area are a national treasure! Hopefully, with a completed power contract and the resulting job security my wife son, and I will be able to enjoy Oregon's shoreline for many years to come. Thanks for giving me the opportunity to speak.
- TDS090208 -
Hart/Idaho Consumer-Owned Utilities AssociationDear Mr. Wright, The Board of Directors of Idaho Consumer-Owned Utilities Association (ICUA) is compelled to write you expressing our concern regarding the sale of power to the direct service industry customers at a substantial cost to BPA’s preference customers. ICUA represents twenty-two of the twenty-six rural electric cooperatives and municipalities that provide electrical service in the state of Idaho. ICUA member utilities serve approximately 120,000 consumers throughout Idaho making ICUA ‘collectively’ the second largest utility in the state. On behalf of our member consumers we strongly urge you to recognize that Bonneville’s preference customers should not shoulder the cost of subsidized power for DSI customers. We too have commercial and industrial customers impacted by the difficult economic times and in need of affordable power. We agree with the Idaho congressional delegation that in a letter to you dated November 20, 2008 stated: “This subsidized electric sale is unfair and discriminatory to the public ratepayers in Idaho and the rest of the northwest.” Sincerely, Will Hart Executive Director, ICUA
- TDS090209 -
Manager/Alcoa
- TDS090210 -
Borges/Canby Utility
- TDS090211 -
Sabala/Douglas Electric CooperativeAugust 3, 2009 Mr. Allen Burns D-7 Acting Deputy Administrator Bonneville Power Administration P.O. Box 3621 Portland, OR 97208-3621 Re: D-7 (Draft Term Sheet – Alcoa and CFAC) Dear Mr. Burns: I am writing to you regarding the Bonneville Power Administration’s (BPA’s) July 17 proposal to offer a power sales contract to Alcoa and Columbia Falls Aluminum Company (CFAC). First, Douglas Electric Cooperative fully supports the comments of both the Pacific Northwest Generating Cooperative (PNGC) and the Public Power Council (PPC). I appreciate the opportunity to provide additional input on BPA’s proposal. As you are aware, BPA has no statutory obligation to serve either Alcoa or CFAC and by doing so, under the terms outlined, significantly increases the risk and costs to BPA and its preference customers. Douglas Electric Cooperative is a member-owned rural electric cooperative headquartered in Roseburg, Oregon. It is hard for me to understand how BPA can support this proposal, while all of our local lumber mills, boat manufacturers, and conductor manufacturer are either closed or substantially curtailed, within and around our service territory. This proposal will add additional pressure to our retail rates, that our customers simply cannot afford. BPA’s proposal to purchase the necessary power, at market rates, and sell it to Alcoa and CFAC, at the IP rate, will assure a net loss to BPA. Alcoa and CFAC will be subsidized by all customers of consumer-owned utilities in the region. As a result, the region-wide electric rate increase, to be imposed on our customers, will cause the loss of additional jobs in the communities we serve, off-setting any potential gain by either Alcoa or CFAC operating. We hope that you will reconsider this costly and unfair proposal, and abandon BPA’s intention to serve Alcoa and CFAC. Thank you for the opportunity to comment. Sincerely, DOUGLAS ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE Dave Sabala General Manager
- TDS090212 -
Davison/Industrial Customers of Northwest Utilities
- TDS090213 -
Council/Public Power Council
- TDS090214 -
Nelson/Springfield Utility Board
- TDS090215 -
Brandland/42nd Legislative District, Whatcom County, WA StateAS I represent the legislative district where Alcoa Intalco Works is located, I am writing to express my support of Alcoa Intalco Works' power contract to maintain the plant's aluminium production. I appreciate the progress and open dialogue between BPA and Intalco which brings us to the milestone Term Sheet framework for the contract between BPA and Intalco at the IP rate to continue at least two potlines which are needed to remain cost effective. I support the contract proposal of a mid- to long-term contract as it will provide great security for employees and the local community which I represent. I appreciate your positive response to a mid- to long-term contract supplying enough power at the IP rate to operate two potlines at the Alcoa Intalco Works plant. Senator Dale E. Brandland, 42nd District Whatcom County/Washington State
- TDS090216 -
Chalupa/selfOur community's businesses and citizens are hurting because of these tough economic times. I'm writing to let you know that BPA's proposal to provide half a billion dollars to Alcoa, Inc, and Glencore/CFAC at the expense of public power consumers is poor public policy. Even worse, I understand that BPA is willing to cover the risk of these companies walking away from their power purchase, leaving public power consumers financially responsible for those expenses. BPA should not enter into any arrangement that uses our commmunity's dollars to benefit private companies it chooses to prefer over us. Increasing the power rates we pay will lead to unjustified further job losses and difficulties for our region. Our community and its jobs are just as important as those that BPA is targeting. Regards, J. Chalupa
- TDS090217 -
Flowers/Idaho Falls Power
- TDS090218 -
/Ex-AlcoansAs an Ex-Alcoan who was "laid-off", I was inside and am extremely aware of the situation. Alcoa, as a multinational corporation, should not be subsidized by anyone. They are a great deal responsible for flooding the market with their product and are now directly responsible for their current financial situation. When the prices for aluminum were high, I remember a lot of mandatory overtime. Next thing we hear is how all the world warehouses are over filled with raw aluminum and now smelters are having to lay off employees that worked hard for them and curtailment. You will receive almost no support for smelters by anyone understanding that their taxes are subsidizing them. All the thank you letters are form letters from current employees and supervisors, most being told to do so, and are recognized favorably for doing so. Do NOT subsidize Aluminum smelters like Alcoa Intalco Works. They have billions of dollars with which to pay their own way....just like us smaller people have to do!
- TDS090219 -
Schon/SelfDear Administrator Wright: I want to thank your agency for your work in developing the term sheet for potential power service to Alcoa, Intalco Aluminum. As you know, Alcoa Intalco has been a customer of BPA for over 40 years and would like to continue to be a customer of BPA for the long term future. Aluminum is important not only to the region but also to the United States. It is a strategic metal and will not only help in the economy of the North west but will also help with the world efforts to reduce carbon emissions. Providing power to Intalco will avoid job losses and tremendous hardship to the local area and region. Intalco has and will continue to partner with the community, other businesses, and even the State of Washington on important initiatives such as Greenhouse gas reduction if it can find a way to make aluminum at a profit in these tough economic times. AS you know better than I, Intalco can also play an important role for the region, providing an interruptible pwer load which will help balance new initiatives and future power demands. Sincerely, Jim Schon
- TDS090220 -
Kremen/Whatcom CountyOn behalf of Whatcom County citizens, I am very much in favor and fully support the BPA contract with Alcoa. Whatcom County is facing the highest unemployment rate since 2002 – 8.1% in February. This is up 3.1% from February 2008, the biggest rise since at least 1990, the first year of comparable data, and it is expected to rise in the foreseeable future. I could continue to quote statistics about downward trends in the real estate market and government agencies and school districts struggling to make ends meet, but the bottom line is we are hurting and cannot afford to lose any more family-wage jobs. Current economic circumstances aside, Intalco is a responsible corporate citizen we need to retain. The spirit in which Intalco management and employees alike engage in our community is second to none and I fear that if the plant was to shutdown a very large hole would be left in its place. Alcoa employees have been tireless volunteers in the community for more than 40 years. They contribute company and personal time to many community causes, embodying the spirit of community service and volunteerism I think we all aspire to. We truly appreciate your support of Alcoa in Bellingham and hope that this contract will make it possible to move forward and continue to grow this business.
- TDS090221 -
Toulson/Snohomish County PUD
|
|
|
Finance & Rates
